Critically endangered metals

Former geologist James Cooper explains why a gap in new discovery presents enormous opportunity for explorers targeting critical metals
James Cooper

Fat Tail Investment Research

EV cars, 3D printed houses, automated homes and ultra-efficient renewable energy power generators are just some of the future innovations leading us to a better, cleaner world.

And with the stroke of a pen, governments across the globe have started this carbon free, pollution free, automated utopia we all want.

Yet, there is one KEY factor that environmentalists, leaders, CEO’s, celebrities have left out...

How do we get the raw materials to build this multi-trillion dollar dreamland?

A Transition Nightmare awaits as we move from Carbon to Renewable Energy

Knowing whether the world can actually supply the critical metals needed to fuel the ‘green revolution’ would be a logical first step before going about an ambitious carbon reduction policy.

Can we actually get enough stuff out of the ground to build the replacement technology?

This is not a question on the radar for the politicians, climate scientists or advocates pushing change.

Commodity experts were not invited to the Paris or Glasgow Climate summits.

It was a decision reserved for governments and climate scientists.

Yet the main limiting factor for all this policy driven change is the availability of raw materials.

The minerals needed to build wind farms, solar panels, batteries, EV vehicles.

Policy makers have made BIG assumptions that resources will be available.

They’re relying on old economic rules of supply and demand.

Create demand for critical metals and the supply will invariably arrive.

Basic economic theory to them.

However, by pushing this market philosophy onto a finite resource like critical minerals, the demand side of the equation starts to levitate precariously upward.

Supply of critical metals is not a straightforward process of increasing production like it would be for iron ore mining.

To meet spectacular demand for critical metals requires vast global investment to drive exploration.

Then, assuming exploration is successful…

It would require enormous global capital to build sophisticated processing facilities required to extract critical metals from ore.

Again, a process that requires far more infrastructure and technology compared with the relatively straightforward method of processing iron ore.

What does all this mean for commodity investors?

Well, while ‘Ass-umptions make an Ass’ out of our leaders, they’ve unknowingly gifted you a once in a generation investment opportunity.

Remember, it takes at least 15 years to bring an ore body from discovery to production.

That’s assuming an economically viable source of critical metals can be discovered in the first place.

It all boils down to a massive re-pricing of mining companies that ALREADY own the exceedingly difficult to find critical metal deposits.

But first, What Makes a Metal so ‘Critical’ in the First Place?

The ‘Great Green Energy Transition’ isn’t the only sector that will need critical metals in the future.

It includes ALL segments of the economy.

A tidal wave of changing technologies means an enormous shift in the types of raw materials needed.

From healthcare, defence, manufacturing, the commercial need for these metals is diverse.

Critical minerals includes those traditional elements like copper, nickel, and aluminium.

It also includes lithium, cobalt, and the Rare Earth Elements (REEs).

But thanks to the birth of highly specialised technologies, obscure sounding metals, also sit at the forefront in determining the way we live into the future.

Without trying to make this sound like a Year 10 Science class, we only need to take a peek at some of the bizarre sounding metals now shaping future investment in mining.

There’s promethium, a healer, and a weapon.

This element is a critical component for making pacemakers but it’s also used for building self-guided missiles in defence.

Or niobium, scientists have capitalised on its unique ‘superconducting’ properties allowing them to develop new kinds of superfast, highly energy efficient large-scale computing, without the need for semiconductors.

Or there’s zirconium, a key metal used for cladding nuclear reactor fuel cells.

The potential for critical metals is endless, the only limitation is SUPPLY.

It’s no wonder resource companies have started eagerly sifting through old drill core in the hope of finding a strike in critical metals.

It’s an inexpensive strategy that could gift a company an instant windfall.

Finding a mineable body of one of these modern day gems would be an immediate game changer for the company.

But these small wins won’t be enough to supply the breathtaking level of demand that’s coming…

One example, a mineral known as natural graphite, used in cathodes of lithium-ion batteries needs a mere 600% increase to its current production to meet future demand!

That’s the outlook published by Benchmark Mineral Intelligence.

Are these Metals really that Rare?

The answer to this question has been muddied by those unwilling to accept supply issues.

Some pundits have argued the so called ‘critical metals’ are not in fact rare at all.

While this may be true in some instances, it’s a distraction from reality in terms of how it affects supply.

Critical metals must be found in high enough concentration to allow economic extraction.

In summarising the scarcity of Rare Earth Elements (REE’s) Geoscience Australia explains:

Although these elements [Rare Earths Elements] are referred to as rare they are not particularly rare in the earth’s crust. Cerium is the 25th most abundant crustal element and lutetium, the scarcest REE, is about the 60th most abundant. However, it is not common for them to occur in conencentrations sufficient to support commercial mining operations.

This is the key point.

Some critical minerals occur in the Earth’s crust at elevated levels but this doesn’t equate to a ready supply.

The issue of Scarcity is based on the ability to support commercial mining operations.

For Rare Earth Elements and many other critical metals finding ACTUAL mineable ore bodies is what makes these particular metals RARE.

You also need to consider this…

Organisation tasked with Calculating Global Mineral Supply

One of the key authorities on the topic of determining the supply of economic minerals is the US Geological Survey (USGS).

As well as having a critical role in monitoring the potential for natural disasters across the US, the organisation has been tasked with the job of calculating the world’s entire supply of raw materials.

From this, the agency drills down to find which metals are ‘critical’.

Not an easy task!

This is not a ‘for fun’ project undertaken by a friendly team of geologists; it is a US government directive to establish the metals needed for economic survival.

This is serious stuff. The USGS sends geologists across the world to define major reserves, even the war torn corners of Afghanistan and Syria are visited to ensure reserves are measured correctly.

This is what the USGS has to say about critical metals:

“A material essential to the economic or national security of the U.S. and which has a supply chain vulnerable to disruption. Critical minerals are also characterized as serving an essential function in the manufacturing of a product, the absence of which would have significant consequences for the economy or national security.”

In February 2022, the organisation released a detailed list of no less than 50 minerals that were deemed as ‘critical’.

Interestingly, the most recent addition was nickel, added just prior to the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

With Russia being a major exporter for nickel, did the USGS know what was coming or was it just a coincidence?

Who knows…

But something you can be certain of, the US organisation that is able to make precise estimates on supply and demand for critical metals.

While many OPEC countries publish their own version of the critical metals list, it’s the USGS that I pay attention too.

When it comes to national security the US does not tread lightly.

With the full backing of the federal government, and close relationships with CIA, the organisation can pierce the deepest corners of the planet and assess impending supply issues for raw materials.

The USGS gives you direct scientific evidence for future supply constraints.

Another crucial tool in the arsenal of commodity investors trying to uncover the facts.

We’ll delve more into critical metals in our next issue.

But for now, what does this all mean?

A looming supply crunch for critical metals is coming.

But major mining conglomerates have been exceedingly slow to act…

They’ve become complacent thanks to reaching the cream phase of their production lifecycle just as commodity prices rise.

BHP, FMG, Rio Tinto have all grown fat on the hard work and capex expenditure deployed during the last mining boom.

Their multi-decade old mines continue to reap enormous profits with relatively small capital outlay… gifting shareholders outsized dividends.

But a problem looms… Mines are a depleting asset.

Miners must acquire new mines or lead discovery so they can continue operating.

However, lack of investment into project development, more than a decade of avoiding spending on exploration for organic growth, means these big miners rest on borrowed time…

The next generation of new critical metal discoveries has been left to the small cap explorers.

Meaning acquisition is the only option available for the majors to replace exhausted reserves.

As major mining companies wake up to this realisation, bidding amongst the giants is set to become fierce.

That’s why the biggest opportunity in the years ahead will be amongst the small cap explorers.

Its part of a new project I’ve launched with Fat Tail Investment Research where I apply my experience as former exploration geologist… Analysing the small-cap stocks with the highest probability for success.

If you’re interested in finding out the details on how I select exploration companies… You can do so here.

........
All advice is general in nature and has not taken into account your personal circumstances. Please seek independent financial advice regarding your own situation, or if in doubt about the suitability of an investment. Any actual or potential gains in these reports may not include taxes, brokerage commissions, or associated fees.

James Cooper
Commodities Analyst and Editor
Fat Tail Investment Research

James is a former exploration geologist, turned mining analyst with postgraduate qualifications and has extensive operational and financial experience in the mining industry. He’s worked for major and junior companies throughout Australia and...

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.

Comments

Sign In or Join Free to comment