4 things to look for under the bonnet of your ETF

VanEck’s Arian Neiron on hidden concentration, company fundamentals and whether your ETF is doing its job, plus three funds to watch for 2027.
Vishal Teckchandani

Livewire Markets

VanEck's global CEO, Jan van Eck and its Asia-Pacific CEO, Arian Neiron
VanEck's global CEO, Jan van Eck and its Asia-Pacific CEO, Arian Neiron

For the past decade, the exchange-traded fund (ETF) playbook for Australian investors has been wonderfully simple: buy the market, keep fees low, and don’t worry about concentration risk. After all, she'll be right - these funds hold so many companies!

But as market themes like artificial intelligence and the commodity boom that powers it have evolved, the risk hiding inside standard indices has become extreme. As Arian Neiron, CEO of VanEck Asia-Pacific, points out, investors need to look past headline fees and examine what is actually driving their portfolios.

“The number of stocks [in an ETF] is a poor proxy for diversification - what matters is the concentration of risk beneath them,” he argues.

Neiron has spent 14 years watching how Australians invest in ETFs, a journey that began in 2012 when he flew to New York to pitch the company's global CEO, Jan van Eck, on bringing a smarter range of strategies to the local market.

With the current market cycle raising questions about how concentrated market-cap ETFs have become and what’s driving their returns, I asked Neiron what investors should look for under the bonnet of their funds.

Here are four things to check, plus three ETFs on his watchlist for 2027.

1. How concentrated is the ETF?

Neiron challenges the idea that a traditional market-cap index offers effective shelter through "strength in numbers" - the comforting notion that if one company, sector, or theme hits a rough patch, its impact will be minimised by the fact there are many other holdings in the portfolio.

But by weighting companies purely by size, standard indices automatically herd investors into the most-crowded trades.

Today, banks and resources in Australia, and AI and technology stocks in the US, share a staggering common number: 55. That’s right - they make up roughly 55% of the ASX 200 and the S&P 500 indices, respectively.

Look to South Korea to see what happens when a single sector and a few companies grow too dominant. Its KOSPI index of more than 800 companies crashed more than 40% between June and November 2026 after its two largest tech blue-chips, Samsung and SK Hynix, tumbled during the AI sell-off. Those two stocks make up nearly 70% of the index.

The KOSPI Composite Index's one-year performance (Source: Yahoo!)
The KOSPI Composite Index's one-year performance (Source: Yahoo!)

"A market-capitalisation index is, in effect, a single macro position: long the largest companies at whatever valuations and concentrations the cycle has delivered," Neiron warns.

While he isn’t suggesting Australian and US markets will see an identical outcome, the Korean example offers a harsh case study in what happens when index concentration gets out of hand, and why capital allocation should never be a "set and forget" exercise.

2. Does it care about fundamentals at all?

When investors compare standard ASX 200, international equity, and fixed-income trackers, the only real difference they usually see is the fee. But Neiron points out that buying the whole market means buying the good, the bad, and the mediocre indiscriminately.

In an environment where borrowing costs remain elevated, businesses with weak balance sheets and heavy debt struggle to fund their own growth, yet a standard market-cap index doesn’t screen companies for earnings stability or balance sheet strength.

"With inflation persistent, growth moderating and the cost of capital elevated, the ability to earn high returns on equity, sustain stable earnings and carry modest leverage becomes more valuable.

Companies with those characteristics are better placed to fund their own growth and absorb cost pressure than those that depend on cheap capital."

That is why increasing numbers of Australian investors - as Neiron puts it - are "graduating" from standard ETFs into smart beta strategies, which utilise rules that screen for specific factors like quality and value to navigate different phases of the market cycle. More of them are comfortable with low-cost portfolio cores, but want to play markets in a different way to control the risks.

Smart beta funds now account for about 16% of Australian ETF assets, highlighting how far local portfolio sophistication has matured.

"From our recent Smart Beta Survey, advisers are increasingly allocating to smart beta strategies, with around 80% of advisers seeing these strategies as good value for money," he says.

Neiron also reminds investors that a cheap and cheerful broad-market approach has its seasons. The low interest rates of the 2010s helped fuel widespread gains, but different conditions can favour different investment styles.

Value stocks led in the early 2000s before enduring a lost decade after the GFC. More recently, they’ve returned to favour.

Neiron points to the VanEck International Value ETF (ASX: VLUE) as a case in point, noting that after years of trailing the market, it has outperformed over one, three and five years. Quality excelled during value’s lean years and, he says, has also benefited recently as volatility returned.

The lesson is to understand how each exposure behaves across the cycle, while resisting the temptation to chase whichever factor is running hottest.

“Factors unbundle that position into distinct sources of return, such as quality, value, growth and equal weighting, each with its own sensitivity to growth, inflation and interest rates,” he says.

"Used deliberately, they allow investors to diversify away from one exposure and consider each risk rather than inherit it. Used carelessly, they become a rotation strategy in disguise, and the investor swaps a premium for timing risk."

3. How does the index treat companies at the top of the cycle?

Australia’s share market is uniquely narrow and cyclical, structurally tying domestic index returns to the fortunes of raw material extraction and consumer lending. 

Neiron notes that during favourable parts of the commodity cycle, local resource companies can score exceptionally high on traditional headline metrics, masking underlying vulnerabilities. If an index relies solely on size or basic trailing numbers, investors can easily end up heavily overexposed to cyclical sectors right before a sharp macroeconomic downturn.

Furthermore, applying standard, unadjusted screens can lead investors straight into companies that look profitable largely due to temporary price spikes in global commodities rather than sustainable operational execution.

"Australia’s narrow, cyclical share market presents different construction challenges from a broad international universe. Strong reported profitability can reflect a favourable commodity cycle, so it is important to understand how a methodology assesses the durability of those earnings."

Without deliberate screening for structural earnings stability and balance sheet strength, local portfolios remain dangerously chained to the unpredictable, boom-and-bust swings of global commodity prices and domestic banking cycles.

4. Is the ETF doing its job?

While low fees are undeniably important for Australian investors, Neiron argues that using cost as the sole basis for an investment decision is a dangerous trap.

A cheap management fee tells you nothing about whether a portfolio is structurally sound, whether it is dangerously concentrated in a handful of overcrowded mega-caps, or whether it can withstand sudden economic shocks.

"Fees, while an important consideration, we think are secondary to the index that drives the ETF."

Rather than panicking during short-term underperformance or obsessing over shaving a few basis points off a management expense ratio, Neiron argues that investors should judge a fund by its underlying construction methodology

The critical test is not just what it costs, but whether the fund behaves predictably and faithfully executes its stated mandate across different phases of the market cycle.

"A style or a factor that falls out of favour will lag but the better question is whether the strategy is behaving as its label says it should."

The 2027 outlook: separating economic growth from share returns

Looking ahead to 2027, Neiron warns investors not to confuse a growing economy with guaranteed sharemarket returns.

While the US economy continues to expand and artificial intelligence infrastructure offers substantial opportunities, massive capital spending alone does not automatically create a compelling investment case.

"Investors need to assess who earns the revenue, who bears the costs and how much future success is already reflected in valuations. Another important point is that fundamentals do matter."

Closer to home, Australian investors face a markedly different macroeconomic squeeze. Following the Reserve Bank of Australia’s fifth cash rate hike of 2026 - pushing the target rate to 4.85%, its highest level since 2008 - companies are being hit from both sides. Persistent inflation is driving up operating costs while slowing consumer activity is dampening demand.

In this environment, Neiron emphasises that earnings resilience, balance sheet strength, and valuation discipline will separate the winners from the laggards. 

He also notes that cash deserves a place in portfolios again. At 4.85%, cash delivers a meaningful nominal yield, though investors should remember that with inflation still elevated, cash protects capital more reliably than purchasing power and should match liquidity needs rather than replace growth assets.

Three VanEck ETFs on Neiron’s watchlist for 2027

To navigate where we are in markets, Neiron highlights three funds that take a more deliberate approach to portfolio construction:

  • VanEck Australian Quality Plus ETF (ASX: AQTY): Built specifically for Australia's concentrated market, AQTY uses a custom index to evaluate profitability, earnings durability, and low debt, while applying valuation and low-volatility screens. With the cash rate at 4.85% pressuring domestic earnings, Neiron points out that local portfolios require deliberate screening:

    "When domestic margins face a squeeze from higher borrowing costs, investors need to look past raw size and target companies that can organically fund their balance sheets," Neiron says.

  • VanEck MSCI International Quality ETF (ASX: QUAL) Tracking developed-market companies with high returns on equity and low financial leverage, QUAL targets businesses capable of self-funding their growth when capital is expensive. It serves as a strong defensive tilt alongside a standard global index fund. Neiron emphasises the global application:

    "International exposure is not just about buying foreign tickers; it is about securing companies with pricing power and pristine balance sheets that can weather any macroeconomic slowdown."

  • VanEck Cash Plus Active ETF (ASX: MONY): With cash finally delivering meaningful nominal yields, Neiron argues investors shouldn't leave liquidity idle. Charging 0.15% per annum, MONY invests in short-term money market and investment-grade credit securities to pay monthly income above the bank bill index, though it carries unit price fluctuation and credit risks. On managing cash dynamically, Neiron notes:

    "When cash earns as much as it does today, how it is invested matters. Investors shouldn't leave capital sitting idle when active short-term strategies can work harder while managing risk."

    ........
    Livewire gives readers access to information and educational content provided by financial services professionals and companies ("Livewire Contributors"). Livewire does not operate under an Australian financial services licence and relies on the exemption available under section 911A(2)(eb) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in respect of any advice given. Any advice on this site is general in nature and does not take into consideration your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before making a decision please consider these and any relevant Product Disclosure Statement. Livewire has commercial relationships with some Livewire Contributors.

    1 topic

    1 fund mentioned

    Vishal Teckchandani
    Lead Investment Writer & Presenter
    Livewire Markets

    I have over 15 years’ experience covering financial markets and property, with a particular interest in ETFs and personal finance. I split my time between Australia and Canada to bring a global perspective to my work.

    I would like to

    Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

    Personal Information Collection Statement
    Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.

    Comments

    Sign In or Join Free to comment