Bank account or ETF? A practical guide to managing investment cash

The headline yield tells only part of the story – these are the trade-offs between bank deposits and listed alternatives.
Patrick Poke

Livewire Markets

A reader recently asked whether listed investments could provide an alternative to savings accounts paying around 5.5%, particularly when the best rates are capped at relatively modest balances.

There are several options, ranging from ETFs holding bank deposits to funds investing in investment-grade floating-rate bonds. However, their advantages are not always a higher return.

A competitive savings account can pay more than a cash ETF, without brokerage costs and with government deposit protection on eligible balances. For some investors, that may already meet the need.

For others, account eligibility, balance caps, monthly conditions or the convenience of holding money within a brokerage account can change the comparison. 

Savings rates look attractive, but check which rate you will receive

In late 2021 and early 2022, the RBA's average advertised bonus savings rate was just 0.25%. Today's offers look considerably more appealing.

These examples illustrate the range available:

Type of offer Advertised rate Main qualifications
Major bank – ongoing bonus savings 5.60% p.a. Grow the balance by at least $100 each month, excluding interest
Major bank – age-restricted bonus savings 6.20% p.a. Ages 18–40; first $150,000; balance-growth conditions and 20 eligible debit-card purchases each month
Smaller bank – introductory savings 6.50% p.a. for 4 months New savings customers; first $500,000; grow the balance by $100 monthly. Currently reverts to 5.90% if the growth condition continues to be met
Smaller bank – ongoing savings without monthly activity conditions 5.75% p.a. First $50,000; lower rates apply to subsequent balance tiers

Sources: Provider announcements and product terms. All rates are variable. These examples are personal accounts; availability and terms can differ for SMSFs, trusts and companies. 

Three descriptions matter here:

  • Introductory: a temporary offer, often restricted to new customers. Check the rate after it expires.
  • Ongoing conditional bonus: no scheduled introductory expiry, but the higher rate must be earned repeatedly.
  • Ongoing unconditional: no monthly activity test, although balance tiers and eligibility restrictions may still apply.

A condition doesn't necessarily make an account unsuitable. A regular deposit or spending requirement may be easy for one person and inconvenient for another.

But missed conditions can be expensive. The ACCC found that, on average, 71% of bonus-interest accounts did not receive bonus interest in a given month during the first half of 2023. 

A separate distinction applies to non-banks. One investment platform currently advertises a 6.20% target return, net of fees, with daily withdrawal requests, or 6.70% with quarterly access. These are managed-fund investments, not bank deposits, so neither the targeted return nor the capital is guaranteed.

Higher interest does not necessarily mean more purchasing power

Comparing today's best advertised rate with the latest annual inflation reading mixes a current offer with a backward-looking statistic. A fairer historical comparison follows savings rates and inflation across matching periods.

Using the RBA's monthly advertised bonus savings series, the results were:

Annualised measure Two years to March 2022 Two years to September 2026
Nominal return, with monthly interest reinvested 0.50% 4.60%
CPI inflation 3.10% 3.60%
Real return before tax −2.5% 1.00%

Source: Author's calculations using RBA Table F4 and ABS quarterly CPI. Bonus conditions are assumed to be met. 

In the earlier period, an illustrative $100,000 would have grown to about $101,059 before tax. Yet its purchasing power would have fallen to approximately $95,129 in starting-period dollars.

Over the more recent period, it would have grown to about $109,344, equivalent to approximately $101,938 after inflation.

Cash therefore became substantially more rewarding, but the increase in purchasing power was smaller than the increase in the account balance. And tax can reduce that gain further.

The central long-term risk of cash is that preserving the dollar balance does not necessarily preserve what it can buy. For money needed soon, accepting some inflation risk may serve a purpose. For reserves left untouched for years, the cumulative effect can seriously erode purchasing power. 

Three different jobs for investment cash

A bucket framework is one way to distinguish immediate investment money from reserves that can tolerate some additional risk. It does not require fixed percentages, or the use of every bucket.

Household emergency savings sit outside this framework – I'm talking about money held within an investment portfolio here. 

Bucket 1: Money available for immediate investment needs

The first bucket prioritises access and nominal capital preservation. It might fund a share purchase, meet an approaching settlement obligation or cover another immediate portfolio payment.

An eligible at-call deposit within the Financial Claims Scheme limit offers a strong starting point. The scheme protects up to $250,000 per account holder per authorised deposit-taking institution, or ADI. Deposits across brands sharing an ADI are aggregated. 

There are two separate caps to check: the balance eligible for the advertised interest rate, and the balance covered by the scheme. 

It's also worth remembering that money in an external savings account may need transferring to a broker, subject to transfer limits and processing times.

A cash ETF such as Betashares Australian High Interest Cash ETF (ASX: AAA) holds bank deposits, but access requires selling units. It may be operationally useful where a broker permits sale proceeds to fund another purchase and the settlement dates align. Check with your broker to see if that applies to you. 

Crucially, AAA does not give the investor the same government guarantee as an eligible deposit. Brokerage, bid–ask spreads and trading hours also matter.

For this bucket, accepting a slightly lower return may be the cost of having usable funds when required.

Bucket 2: A reserve to replenish the first bucket

The second bucket provides additional funding when the immediately available balance has been drawn down or needs rebuilding.

Enhanced-cash funds may have a role here. These invest in combinations of deposits, bank bills, commercial paper and other high-quality, short-term debt. Both interest-rate sensitivity and exposure to changing credit spreads are important, but the idea is to keep the increase small. 

Examples include iShares Enhanced Cash ETF (ASX: ISEC) and Betashares Australian Cash Plus Active ETF (ASX: MMKT). Other funds in the wider short-term universe appear in the table below.

However, an enhanced-cash label does not make funds interchangeable. Their permitted investments, credit quality and maximum duration can differ. The PIMCO Short Term Active Yield Active ETF (ASX: EARN), for example, has a stated duration range of zero to one year. That permits more interest rate exposure than a portfolio resetting within a few weeks.

Very short-dated government securities may also serve a reserve role, but long term government bonds can see significant changes in capital value when rates rise or fall. For example, one ASX-listed ETF which holds long term Australian Government Bonds fell by more than 15% when rates rose in 2021-2022. 

Bucket 3: A deeper reserve in floating-rate credit

The third bucket accepts more credit risk for money unlikely to be needed at short notice. It would normally be drawn on after the more liquid reserves, including to replenish them.

Senior investment-grade floating-rate bond funds are one possible exposure.

Betashares Australian Bank Senior Floating Rate Bond ETF (ASX: QPON) holds senior bank bonds. VanEck Australian Floating Rate ETF (ASX: FLOT) and Vanguard Australian Floating Rate Bond Index ETF (ASX: VFLT) provide broader floating-rate bond exposure.

Floating coupons reset with short-term benchmark rates, limiting sensitivity to changes in interest rates. Income can fall when those benchmark rates decline. 

Don't overlook credit risk though – prices can fall if investors demand a larger margin for lending to an issuer, even without a default. A market sell-off may create both attractive share prices and weaker credit prices. This deeper reserve could therefore be down when an investor wants to deploy it.

Fixed-rate bonds can have an important portfolio role, but their interest-rate exposure places them in a different allocation from the reserves discussed here. Subordinated debt, hybrids, leveraged credit and high-yield strategies also extend beyond this article's scope.

Listed options to investigate

The following products span the cash and short-duration universe discussed above. Inclusion is not a suitability assessment or a ranking.

Exposure ASX code and fund Published management fee/cost p.a.
Bank deposits AAA – Betashares Australian High Interest Cash ETF 0.18%
Short-term money markets BILL – iShares Core Cash ETF 0.07%
Enhanced cash ISEC – iShares Enhanced Cash ETF 0.12%
Cash plus MMKT – Betashares Australian Cash Plus Active ETF 0.18%
Cash plus MONY – VanEck Cash Plus Active ETF 0.15%
Active cash and short-term investments FSCF – First Sentier Active Cash Fund Active ETF 0.20%
Short-duration investment-grade bonds EARN – PIMCO Short Term Active Yield Active ETF 0.29%
Senior Australian bank floating-rate bonds QPON – Betashares Australian Bank Senior Floating Rate Bond ETF 0.22%
Australian-dollar floating-rate bonds FLOT – VanEck Australian Floating Rate ETF 0.22%
Australian-dollar corporate floating-rate bonds VFLT – Vanguard Australian Floating Rate Bond Index ETF 0.15%

Sources: Issuer product pages and disclosures. Other fees and costs may apply. The funds do not provide an individual investor with Financial Claims Scheme deposit protection. Check each fund's PDS and TMD for its permitted exposures, risks and intended investment timeframe.

Some reserves may remain in the first bucket indefinitely. Replenishment can also occur before a bucket is exhausted. 

What could make a listed alternative worthwhile?

Start with the realistic comparison. AAA reported a cash yield after management fees of 4.92% on 16 November. That is below the 5.75% personal savings offer above, even before trading costs. So yield alone would not explain choosing AAA over that account.

For an SMSF unable to open the personal account, a larger balance exceeding its top-rate tier, or money otherwise earning little in a settlement account, 4.92% may look more attractive. 

Check usable liquidity. ASX ETFs normally settle two business days after trading. A broker may allow reinvestment of unsettled sale proceeds before withdrawal is possible – check with your broker to see if this applies. 

Allow for trading costs and holding time. A 0.25-percentage-point annual yield advantage is only $25 on $10,000 over a full year, before tax. Brokerage and spreads can absorb a meaningful share, especially for short holding periods.

Compare equivalent yield measures. A trailing distribution yield describes past payments. A portfolio yield or yield to maturity uses current holdings and assumptions. Neither guarantees the next year's return. Annualising one unusually large monthly distribution can also give a misleading impression of recurring income.

Look at total return. A distribution is not an extra return on top of an unchanged unit price – the price normally adjusts when the distribution is paid. Capital movements and distributions are both important. 

Check payment and reinvestment arrangements. Monthly distributions may arrive days after the ex-date. A distribution reinvestment plan can also leave a small new holding after an investor has sold their original units.

A savings account may already provide an attractive combination of return, access and protection. Listed alternatives broaden the options, but each introduces trade-offs.

The question to ask yourself is what the money needs to do, and whether the additional income or convenience adequately compensates for what changes.

........
Livewire gives readers access to information and educational content provided by financial services professionals and companies ("Livewire Contributors"). Livewire does not operate under an Australian financial services licence and relies on the exemption available under section 911A(2)(eb) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) in respect of any advice given. Any advice on this site is general in nature and does not take into consideration your objectives, financial situation or needs. Before making a decision, please consider these and any relevant Product Disclosure Statement. Livewire has commercial relationships with some Livewire Contributors.

1 topic

Patrick Poke
Managing Editor (Editorial)
Livewire Markets

Patrick is the Managing Editor (Editorial) at Livewire Markets, returning to the team after a four year hiatus. His focus is on editorial strategy, development, and of course, he still loves to write, host, and present when the opportunity arises....

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.

Comments

Sign In or Join Free to comment