Timing is everything: When to sell an investment property before retirement
That was the debate playing out between Leo, 59, and Sophia, 57. Having run their own business for many years, they entered their late 40s with modest super balances. Through substantial contributions and disciplined saving, they’ve grown their combined super to $800,000, while also building up a family home worth $1.4 million and an investment property worth $1.1 million.
The trouble is, a significant share of their investable wealth is concentrated in that single property, and the couple can’t agree on what to do with it. Helping them work through the decision is Northeast Wealth director James O’Reilly.
The situation
- Leo, 59: earning $80,000 a year
- Sophia, 57: earning $160,000 a year
- Planned retirement date: 1 July 2029
- Current living expenses: $135,000 a year, including financial support for their youngest daughter’s university education
- Family home: $1.4 million, no mortgage
- Investment property: $1.1 million, originally bought for $320,000, earning $39,000 a year in rent with $8,000 a year in expenses
- Investment property mortgage: $400,000
- Cash savings: $100,000
- Super: Leo $320,000, Sophia $480,000
Their goals
- Self-fund their retirement
- Spend $120,000 a year in retirement, including regular trips to visit family in Europe and the US and to see more of Australia
- Keep their $100,000 in cash as an emergency reserve
- Decide how best to structure their assets before retiring
If you'd like some general guidance on your own financial situation, email the Livewire team at [email protected] and your scenario could feature in a future edition.
Getting the retirement budget right
Leo and Sophia initially estimated they’d need $102,000 a year in retirement. They arrived at that figure by taking their current spending and removing costs for their daughter's university and other expenses likely to stop once they retired.
But after talking through their goals in more detail, particularly their plans for regular overseas travel, O’Reilly agreed with them that $120,000 a year was a more realistic number.
That $18,000 difference is a reminder that many retirees underestimate how much they’ll want to spend, especially in the active early years of retirement.
The couple also wanted to keep their $100,000 in savings untouched. Having experienced periods of financial stress in the past, that cash buffer provides important peace of mind.
Two very different views
Leo wants to keep the property: He sees it as an excellent investment and wants to hold on to it for future growth and rental income, ideally until their super runs out. His main question is whether to use super to repay the $400,000 mortgage when they retire, or keep servicing the loan from the rent.
Sophia wants to sell: She's concerned about having so much of their wealth in a single asset, and worried about running down their super too quickly. She also questions whether property will keep delivering strong growth, particularly given recent changes announced in the federal budget. She would prefer to sell, either now or at retirement, and reinvest in a diversified, liquid portfolio.
Why selling at retirement came out on top
Selling the property when they retire in 2029 produced the strongest result and O’Reilly points to four key benefits.
Lower capital gains tax: With a property bought for $320,000 now worth $1.1 million, the capital gain is substantial. Selling once they’ve stopped working means the gain is taxed when Leo and Sophia have much lower incomes and therefore lower marginal tax rates.
Tax-effective super contributions: In the year they sell, both can make concessional contributions up to the annual cap to reduce their tax bill. Leo can also use unused concessional caps from previous years through catch-up contributions. Sophia can’t, because her projected super balance would make her ineligible in that year.
Tax-free investment income: Moving eligible sale proceeds into super, and then into account-based pensions, means more of their retirement savings can earn investment returns tax-free.
No growing tax bill: Selling removes the prospect of a capital gains tax liability that keeps growing as the property increases in value.
"Selling immediately also offered tax-planning opportunities, including catch-up contributions for Sophia. However, their existing employment income meant the resulting CGT liability was higher, ultimately leaving them with less retirement capital," O'Reilly says.
The problem with holding on
Keeping the property produced weaker results, and the modelling revealed a surprising detail about Leo’s mortgage question.
"Interestingly, there was very little difference between repaying the mortgage immediately at retirement and continuing with minimum repayments," O'Reilly says.
"This was largely because the assumed mortgage interest rate was similar to the expected returns from their relatively conservative superannuation investments. The investment earnings forgone by withdrawing superannuation to repay the debt broadly offset the interest savings."
The bigger issue was sustainability. Under both strategies, Leo and Sophia would run out of super about eight years into retirement. While they’d still have significant wealth tied up in the property, they would be forced to sell it to keep funding their lifestyle and would lose control over when that sale happened.
Keeping the mortgage would also mean most of the rental income would go towards loan repayments during those early retirement years.
“Ultimately, the modelling demonstrated that selling at retirement offered the strongest combination of tax efficiency, diversification, liquidity and long-term retirement sustainability,” O’Reilly says.
O’Reilly also factored in the federal government’s recent capital gains tax reforms, which introduce a minimum 30% tax on certain capital gains accruing from 1 July 2027. His modelling suggests the changes could add about $18,000 to Leo and Sophia’s tax bill. Even so, selling at retirement remained the best strategy.
Should everyone sell before retiring?
O’Reilly is clear that this isn’t a blanket rule: “This is a decision that requires individual modelling, as the characteristics of the property and the owner’s financial circumstances can significantly change the outcome.”
Several factors made selling the right call for Leo and Sophia, and they won’t apply to everyone:
- Their property earns about 3.5% a year in gross rent, which limits how much it can contribute to their retirement income. If they’d instead owned two $550,000 units earning 5–6% yields, the results could have been very different.
- Properties with stronger growth prospects may build more long-term wealth, but also create larger capital gains tax bills down the track. Higher-yielding properties with more modest growth can produce quite different outcomes.
- Leo could use unused concessional caps to reduce his tax bill in the year of the sale, but Sophia couldn’t. Other investors may have different opportunities available.
“Ultimately, there’s no universal answer. The right strategy depends on rental yield, capital growth, tax circumstances, retirement income requirements and personal preferences,” O’Reilly says.
“It’s the interaction of these factors that determines whether holding or selling makes financial sense.”
The bottom line
For Leo and Sophia, the modelling puts the argument to bed and makes the path forward clear. Selling the property in their first year of retirement gives them a lower tax bill, a more diversified portfolio, easier access to their money, and a retirement that doesn’t depend on being forced to sell a property at a time not of their choosing.
The bigger lesson is that the decision depends on the details. Rental yield, growth prospects, tax position and lifestyle goals all interact, and the right answer for one couple could be the wrong one for another.


Editor's note: In Livewire's Ask an Adviser series, we take the real-world financial questions facing Australian investors and ask a financial adviser how they would approach them.
Please note that names and identifying details have been changed for privacy, and some case studies may be representative of similar client situations rather than the circumstances of a single individual. This article contains general information only and does not consider your personal circumstances.
2 topics