Why preparation trumps prediction to navigate interest rate uncertainty

In today’s market discourse, few topics rival the anticipation surrounding the timing of the next potential move by central banks. It’s the number one question on the minds of economists and the focal point of many financial professionals’ endeavours, who invest substantial resources in attempting to predict this metric.

To some, it makes sense why the interest rate timing discussion is on the edge of investor lips. Interest rates serve as a barometer, like the weather or a temperature gauge, providing insight into forthcoming economic conditions. Just as we eagerly await the nightly weather report to decide whether to wear a coat or carry an umbrella the next day, the anticipation of interest rate movements reflects our desire for clarity on financial climates ahead.

Yet, even when the forecast assures us of clear skies, how often are we caught off guard by unpredictable and unforecastable rain, necessitating a last-minute scramble for an umbrella?

Key takeaways

• Forecasts from economists, central bankers, and financial experts are fallible.
• Different asset classes perform in varying phases of the economic cycle, but over the long-run can generate positive real returns.
• Investors can prepare for all market conditions by tuning out the interest rate trajectory noise and instead craft a diversified all-weather portfolio.

Amidst the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic, the Governor of the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) provided guidance to investors, indicating that the RBA wouldn’t raise interest rates until 2024 – a prediction. However, the reality that unfolded was a sharp and unexpected surge in interest rates, marking one of the swiftest rate rises witnessed in decades, alongside our developed nations.

Against a backdrop of a disinflationary environment and what appears to be a peak in interest rates, the dialogue since the start of 2023 has inevitably pivoted towards the anticipation of when interest rates might be cut – a prediction. More recently we’ve seen the market constantly push back their timing of interest rate cuts. Chances of rate cuts (both in Australia and abroad like the US) have decreased with some economists now predicting an interest rate rise instead.(1)

While the market maintains its anticipation of at least one rate cut by the US Federal Reserve before year-end (~90% probability), it’s essential to recognise that new data can swiftly alter these expectations. Predicting the future is a tricky business, even for experts who regularly update their forecasts. Every quarter, the Federal Reserve unveils a set of projections, highlighted by the “dot plot” indicating where policymakers anticipate interest rates heading. Just a short while ago, around mid-March, these dots indicated a consensus for three rate cuts in the year, despite a surprising uptick in inflation. However, circumstances have shifted significantly since then with hotter than estimated inflation data(2), rendering those earlier projections somewhat questionable.

The focus on interest rate predictions has perhaps been overly prominent. Instead, investors would be better served by preparing for all possible scenarios – whether its interest rate holding steady, increasing or decreasing. This underscores the importance of maintaining a diversified portfolio comprising various asset classes as preparation tools, not prediction punts.

For example, investors who predicted that interest rates would stay lower for longer and took on too much duration risk in their fixed income portfolios saw heavy capital losses. Investors holding long duration bonds are still in a 40 to 50% drawdown since 2020. Investors who diversified across various maturity ranges and concentrated on the “belly” of the yield curve were cushioned from significant downturns.

While higher interest rates can be a short-term headwind for asset classes like gold, due to the increased opportunity cost of holding the precious yellow metal, it does not always result in negative returns. Over the past 50 years, gold has shown its defensive abilities to maintain positive returns in different interest rate environments.

The correlations of gold to the broader share market have remained low during different interest rate cycles. While correlations rose slightly during the interest rate hikes in 1994 and in 2004-2006, it has remained range bound and close to zero over the past 30 years.(3) A pivotal characteristic of building an all-weather portfolio to handle all economic conditions is by owning a diversified set of uncorrelated asset classes, of which gold can be a key tenant.

While defensive assets like gold can act as the insurance policy, the growth drivers of portfolios should not be neglected. Instead of investors making sectoral bets based on the short-term interest rate environment, they can look to explore multi-decade investment opportunities like artificial intelligence and technology. While some interest-rate sensitive shares can fall during interest rate hikes due to their longer cash-flow duration profile, over the long-term the broader share market has been able to generate positive real returns that can outperform both cash and bonds. The annualised return on stocks outperformed bonds by 5.8% p.a. during easing cycles, and 3.9% p.a. during hiking cycles.(4)

Predicting interest rates is a challenging endeavour. It’s not just about deciphering interest rates themselves, but also about accurately forecasting a plethora of other economic indicators like economic growth, unemployment, exchange rates, inflation, consumer and business sentiment, and more. Given the unpredictable nature of life’s uncertainties, we seek out experts for their assurance, hoping for their unwavering confidence. Nonetheless, proficiency doesn’t guarantee flawless predictions. In fact, experts often miss the mark. As Warren Buffett once said, “forecasts create the illusion of apparent precision”.

Investors can benefit from tuning out the noise of economic predictions and forecasts about interest rates, and rather focus on the three areas they can control; 1) the costs they pay; 2) the level of investment risk they take; and 3) their own behaviour. Exchange traded funds (ETFs) offer cost-effective access to diverse investment categories such as shares, bonds, and gold, suitable for long-term holding.

When encountering predictions about the direction of interest rates, it’s wise to pause and consider preparing portfolios to whether various market conditions. Preparation, not prediction, might be the most prudent investment strategy.

Related funds

Global X Physical Gold ETF (ASX: GOLD) invests in physical gold via the stock exchange, offering higher liquidity and removing the need for investors to personally store bullion.

ETF

Global X Physical Gold ETF (GOLD)

Alternative Assets

View

The Global X US Treasury Bond ETF (Currency Hedged) (ASX: USTB) invests in US Treasuries across the yield curve while providing currency hedging.

ETF

Global X US Treasury Bond ETF (Currency Hedged) (USTB)

Global Fixed Income

View