With its shares at half price, does a2 Milk offer value?

Stephen Bennie

Castle Point Funds

The a2 Milk Company (a2) has always been an interesting business, especially over the past five years. From 2015 to 2020 the business delivered explosive growth. Revenues grew from $154 million in the 12 months to June 2015, to $1.73 billion in the 12 months to June 2020. Similarly impressive growth occurred at the bottom line, with profits increasing from $2.4 million to $388 million in the same corresponding periods, an increase of 16,000%! Scant wonder the share price rose from 70c to $20 over those five years of remarkable growth, as the company became a significant player in the global infant milk powder industry.

It is understandable then that by 2020, the company had become a firm favourite with growth investors across Australasia and beyond. Indeed, it is highly unlikely that value investors have ever seriously looked at a2. Even back in 2015 when it was trading around 70c, it was not cheap on historic or current earnings, having been loss-making before carding a modest $2.4 million profit.

And then, in August last year, shortly after reporting its record $388 million profit, it became apparent to management that 2021 was going to be a tough year as Chinese demand for its infant milk formula collapsed amid increased competition. Just how tough 2021 was going to be has been consistently underestimated by management. This resulted in a series of guidance downgrades as the 2021 financial year has progressed. The most recent announcement was perhaps the worst of all, a horrid update that indicated the current run rate was now loss-making and that ageing tins of infant milk formula were being literally dumped down the drain. At the time of writing this, a2 shares have fallen from a high last year of $21.70 to around $6.00, a drop of over 70%.

So, it makes sense to review the investment case of a2 milk via the lens of a value investor, to see if they might be getting excited. Before doing that I wanted to give some context to the discussion and in doing so reference this graphic that I have borrowed from Dundas Global Investors, a very experienced global equity investor based in my hometown of Edinburgh. It looks to show, in a simplified way, the relationship between growth and value investors. 

At their extremes, value and growth investors will generally not own the same company. The cardigan (with leather elbow pads) wearing value investor and the European sports car driving growth investor are not often sighted on the same company’s share registry. But as Dundas point out, there is sometimes a handing over of the baton as value investors sell their winners to growth investors. Sometimes the baton is passed in a different direction as growth investors sell their losers to value investors.

For example, Tourism Holdings was only of any appeal to a value investor back in 2012 when it was trading around 40c. It was a “dog with fleas” that only a cardigan wearer would have had the slightest bit of interest in. New Zealand and Australia were awash with camper vans but down on tourists, consequently, earnings had cratered and so too had the share price. But a value investor that rolled up the sleeves of their cardigan would have been interested in the shares, given that they were trading at a 70% discount to the book value of the campervan fleet. Jump on 6 years, amid industry consolidation and a tourism boom, earnings had recovered and so had the share price. By the point that the Tourism Holdings share price had risen to over $6 and the share registry was strictly the domain of European sports car driving growth investors, as the shares were now trading at a 400% premium to the book value of its campervan fleet. Tourism Holdings was a winner that the cardigans were long gone from by that point.

Returning to a2, the past 9 months have certainly seen growth investors selling a “loser“ but who have they been passing the baton to? The answer requires some guesswork mixed with some deduction. The first cab off the rank would have likely been some growth investors selling to other growth investors, at the first profit warning. The next profit warning would have been a mix of that and a few early GARP investors. These are Growth at Reasonable Price investors; who tend to drive Japanese hot hatches in comfortable knitwear. The next profit warning probably had more growth selling and more GARP investors buying. The next profit warning had tardy growth investors waking up and selling and early GARP investors starting to sell to slightly more battle-hardened GARP investors.

You will notice that I’m hesitant to say that value investors have been buying a2 in any serious way. This is because a2 is not ticking many of the boxes that would normally attract their interest. At current levels a2 is trading at a 380% premium to the book value of its assets, so it is not an asset play. It’s not cheap in terms of current earnings or next year’s expected rebound, the P/E ratio for FY21 is 48x and for FY22 it’s 25x. Another preferred approach for a value investor is to gauge how the current price relates to a normal mid-cycle level of earnings. That approach does not work for a2, there just is not the history that would give any indication of what that number might be. Another metric that would not entice value investors is that the enterprise value of a2 is still 3.1x revenues, which is higher than value investors typically like to pay for a company. The additional stumbling block for value investors with a2 is that its rise was so stratospheric and its subsequent fall so abrupt, that it is nigh on impossible to know what a bedrock steady state earnings might be, never mind trying to assess if it is cheap on that level of earnings.

Looking further down the track, a strong indication that growth and GARP investors are largely gone and that its now mainly owned by cardigan wearing value investors, is that the share price no longer goes down on bad news. That is because value investors are realists and accept that some bad news is part of life. Growth investors detest bad news, it punctures their rosy optimism, as well as the tyres of their European sportscars, and so they sell and are happy to do so at lower prices. Currently with the share price continuing to react badly to negative news, a2 clearly still has plenty of growth and GARP investors on the share registry. And likely only a handful of very early and unusually optimistic value investors.

Four reasons to register for Livewire’s 100 Top-Rated Funds Series

Livewire's Top-Rated Fund Series gives subscribers exclusive access to data and insights that will help them make more informed decisions.

Click here to view the dedicated website, which includes:

  • The full list of Australia’s 100 top-rated funds.
  • Detailed fund profile pages, with data powered by Morningstar.
  • Exclusive interviews with expert researchers from Lonsec, Morningstar and Zenith.
  • Videos and articles featuring 16 top-rated fund managers.
Castle Point has taken all reasonable care in the preparation of these articles, however accepts no responsibility for any errors or omissions contained within. Past performance is not necessarily an indication of future performance. Opinions expressed in these articles are our view as at the date of issue and may change

Stephen Bennie
Castle Point Funds

Stephen has over 25 yrs investment experience & co-founded Castle Point, a NZ boutique fund manager, in 2013. Prior to that he worked at funds management companies in Auckland, London & Edinburgh. Castle Point WINNER FundSource Boutique Manager 2019

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.