Ahead of CSL reporting this morning, here are 5 recent Livewire contributor insights into the stock. The stock is up 27% for the year, and 221% over 5 years, making it something of a poster child for the buy and hold investor. But after a big run, opinions are divergent. James Gerrish of Market Matters included it in his list of 'Go-to stocks starting to crack', while Rob Tucker from Chester Asset Management included it in his list of 5 stocks that could double cash flow in five years. Here's what they are saying:


Rob Tucker, Chester Asset Management


"We see CSL as fair value at current levels, and expect a period of consolidation ahead given the strong price appreciation over the past 6 months. We will look to accumulate on weakness, given we believe, the unique nature of the CSL industry structure and growth profile." (VIEW LINK)


Roger Montgomery, Montgomery Asset Management; and Ben Clark, TMS


In a recent episode of Buy Hold Sell Roger Montgomery described CSL as being ‘frighteningly expensive.’ While Ben Clark could only muster a ‘hold’ as the company had grown to be his biggest portfolio position: (VIEW LINK)



Andrew Tang, Morgans

“We highlight our key candidates that may surprise or disappoint during the upcoming August results season. Vulnerable high PE stocks include Ansell (ANS), CSL (CSL), Cochlear (COH), Domino's (DMP)”: (VIEW LINK)


James Gerrish, Market Matters

CSL has been an amazing performer for many years, but when the stock surges over 50% this calendar year we have to question whether value remains. Over recent weeks CSL has rapidly corrected ~10% but it¹s still trading on Est. P/E for 2017 of 34x earnings which is very much at the rich end of town.




What the brokers are saying


According to FNArena, 6 brokers currently have coverage on CSL Limited with 4 rating the stock a buy / outperform. Morgans and Morgan Stanley are neutral on the stock. The consensus share price target is $137  (Versus current price of $127).   



Please sign in to comment on this wire.