How to tell a bargain from someone else’s problem
An investment marked at $100 is offered to you for $50. Before calling it a bargain, you need to know what it might be worth when you come to sell.
For John Lee, partner at Lexington Partners, that future value matters far more than the size of the discount. Depending on the investment’s prospects, even paying a premium to its reported valuation could make sense.
Lexington buys existing interests in private equity funds, providing an exit for investors who want their capital back. Slower distributions have encouraged some investors to sell, bringing quality assets to market alongside investments that may deserve their discounted prices.
Working out which is which requires looking beyond the portfolio’s holdings. The financial health of the manager, its ability to retain experienced people and its motivation to keep investing can all influence the outcome.
In the interview above, Lee explains how Lexington assesses those opportunities and identifies situations where a lower price won’t change its mind. He also discusses why, when a manager wants to keep an asset for longer, Lexington looks for evidence that it is willing to invest again.
Why good assets come up for sale
A private equity fund typically starts with a long commitment. Institutional investors, known as limited partners (LPs), provide capital to a manager, or general partner (GP), which buys businesses and eventually sells them to return money to investors.
That arrangement commonly runs for 10 years, although extensions can push the eventual exit further out.
An investor who wants their money back before then cannot simply sell units on an exchange. Instead, a buyer such as Lexington Partners can purchase their interest in the existing fund.
For John Lee, a partner at Lexington, the opportunity starts with the different needs of buyer and seller. The seller may want cash even when the underlying investments are performing well.
“Liquidity has been a little bit less than most LPs have desired recently,” he says.
Lee says distributions have been subdued since 2022. While they are recovering, the pace has been slower than many investors would like, encouraging some to sell rather than keep waiting.
Selling only the weakest assets is not necessarily an answer. A buyer may demand a substantial discount, or decline to buy them altogether. To achieve an acceptable price, the seller may need to include better businesses.
A discount is not a valuation
A large discount to a fund’s reported net asset value (NAV) can look appealing. But Lee puts more weight on what the underlying investments could eventually sell for.
“What we care more about is what the assets are going to be worth at the time of exit, which would be in the future.”
His hypothetical example starts with an asset marked at $100. If Lexington believes it could sell for $300 in three years, paying $150 could still allow the buyer to double its capital. That is a 50% premium to the current valuation.
If the same asset is expected to be worth only $100 at exit, achieving the same multiple would require an entry price of $50 – a 50% discount.
The examples depend on the exit assumptions proving correct. The discount alone tells an investor little about the potential outcome.
“So discount is not necessarily an input in our investment decision. It’s actually an output,” Lee says.
Lexington works through a portfolio fund by fund and asset by asset, assessing when the investments might be sold and at what price. Those estimates determine what it is willing to pay.
When a low price is not enough
Buying a portfolio does not mean every investment in it will be equally attractive.
Lee describes situations where a seller has a portfolio that is 90% high quality but needs a buyer for the remaining 10% as well. Lexington may consider the whole package, provided it can assess the weaker holdings and arrive at a price that makes sense.
There are also situations it would rather avoid, regardless of the discount.
One is a manager whose own business may no longer be viable. Difficulty raising subsequent funds can weaken the incentive to keep managing older investments and make it harder to retain the people responsible for them.
The buyer is therefore assessing more than the businesses inside a fund. It also needs confidence that the manager has the capacity and motivation to see those investments through.
The relationships behind the transaction
Knowing the managers matters both when assessing an investment and when trying to complete it.
Longstanding relationships can provide insight into team dynamics, internal politics and the circumstances a manager is navigating. They can also lead to opportunities that are not offered broadly. Lee describes one continuation-vehicle transaction in which a managing partner approached Lexington’s CEO directly with an exclusive opportunity.
“That’s something that has to be built over time institutionally,” he says of the firm’s relationships.
Many deals still come through competitive auctions. Once Lexington has assessed a portfolio, negotiations may involve changing its composition rather than simply moving the price.
For example, removing funds that would dilute the buyer’s expected returns may allow it to pay a smaller discount for the remaining holdings.
Even an agreed price does not guarantee a completed transaction. The managers of the underlying funds generally need to approve the transfer of the fund interests. A manager that does not want a particular buyer as an investor can refuse.
Is the manager willing to invest again
A fund approaching the end of its life may still own a business its manager wants to keep.
One solution is a continuation vehicle: a new fund that acquires the asset, allowing existing investors who want liquidity to sell while others can remain invested.
The question for a new buyer is whether the manager sees further opportunity or is struggling to find another exit.
“We want to buy assets that the GP wants to buy again. They want to be a reinvestor,” Lee says.
Lexington looks for financial commitments that support that conviction. Depending on the transaction, these can include rolling the manager’s performance fees and existing investment into the new vehicle, or requiring fresh capital.
In some cases, the company’s management may also be asked to reinvest commitments and incentives linked to its performance.
Lee also describes seeking investment from the manager’s latest flagship fund. That helps keep the continuation vehicle’s performance within the manager’s ongoing track record.
“I would say incentive alignment is the most important thing: whether the GP is putting their money where their mouth is.”
Designed for long term growth
The Franklin Lexington Private Equity Secondaries Fund provides access to private equity through an underlying diversified portfolio focused on secondary transactions. Find out more here.
1 topic