Ian Macoun: Stepping into the unknown
It’s been 20 years since Pinnacle founder Ian Macoun stepped out of his comfort zone and into the unknown. Leaving a well-paid role as a public servant, Macoun embarked on a journey that has ultimately led to the creation of one of Australia’s most successful funds management businesses.
Pinnacle began in 2006, when Macoun convinced Wilson HTM Investment Group to back his multi-affiliate vision. By 2015, Wilson HTM sold its stockbroking business to bet everything on the multi-affiliate model, and a year later it took the name too, with the listed company becoming Pinnacle Investment Management Group (ASX: PNI). Since then, the firm’s market cap has grown from $250 million to $3.8 billion today. If you had bought and held shares from August 2016 to today, you would have generated a total return more than seven times that of the S&P/ASX 200.
Clearly, Pinnacle has enjoyed an incredible run, growing funds under management and adding fund managers (or affiliates, as they are known) to the firm's stable. But the journey hasn't been all smooth sailing, and the current environment is creating a new set of challenges for Macoun and the broader investment management industry.
As market structures have evolved, the environment for active management has become more challenging; add the natural ebb and flow of market cycles, and there will inevitably be highs and lows. Macoun believes Pinnacle’s model, which he says preserves the environment for investment excellence, is even more relevant and necessary today than it was when he left his public service role more than 20 years ago.
Macoun and Pinnacle are all in on active management: he believes it is possible to find investors who can deliver exceptional returns for their clients. The data suggests that these individuals and teams are few and far between. When I last spoke with Macoun, he told me that just 5% of the investment teams he assesses pass his criteria.
But finding good investment talent is only half the challenge; providing the right environment for them to perform is the key premise underlying Pinnacle’s model. Functions outside the investment process, such as distribution and back-office support, can be specialised and delivered at scale; that’s what Pinnacle brings to the table.
Markets have become more efficient over time, and the skills required to deliver strong performance have changed. Macoun says this environment makes it even more important for fund managers to stay focused and free from the burden and distraction of adjacent but necessary business operations.
In this interview, Macoun reflects on Pinnacle's early days and explains the thinking behind the multi-affiliate model he pioneered. He also shares past and current challenges the firm has navigated, and where he sees the next leg of growth for the business.
You can watch the full interview by clicking on the video player below, or scroll down to read a summary of Ian Macoun’s views on the state of funds management, private credit, and Pinnacle’s next leg of growth.
Topics discussed
- 0:00 - Introduction
- 1:19 - The idea behind Pinnacle (ASX:PNI)
- 3:31 - Stepping into the unknown
- 4:38 - What made the Pinnacle model successful
- 6:40 - Assessing a successful manager in 2026
- 8:51 - The rise of passive and ETFs
- 11:08 - The Your Future, Your Super performance test
- 12:22 - Why five-year timeframes matter
- 13:43 - Scale is not the answer
- 16:57 - The unmet needs for investors
- 18:15 - A difficult period for private credit
- 20:17 - Where are we in the credit cycle
- 21:05 - Growth opportunities
- 22:39 - Taking the Pinnacle model to London
- 26:22 - The offshore growth trend
- 27:07 - Australia as a financial services hub
- 28:41 - Succession at Pinnacle
- 30:19 - Lessons from building Pinnacle
7 key takeaways from Ian Macoun
#1: The secret to investment excellence
Traditional institutions often mash investment teams and corporate operations together, creating dysfunction. Macoun designed Pinnacle to give fund managers complete autonomy over investing while centralising distribution, risk, operations, and technology.
“We’ve had an environment where the investment professionals are front and centre and key, and they can do their best work free from distractions. But equally, you can have excellence in distribution and ops as service providers and getting the benefits of scale.”
#2: Passive ETFs are shaking out poor active managers
While passive strategies have a place in portfolios, Macoun believes the industry has reached extreme heights, pushing capital into the wrong stocks and hurting small caps. Yet he welcomes the discipline ETFs force on the industry by exposing underperformers and creating mispricing opportunities for genuinely skilled stock pickers.
“A lot of money goes into the wrong stocks at the wrong prices, but in time, it’s actually helpful to active. Obviously, you need good active managers or passive doesn't even exist. It's a sort of a parasitic function that relies on talented active people to price things... Passive has been bad for mediocre active, and that’s a good thing. I’ve always said passive will keep active managers honest.”
#3: The ‘Your Future, Your Super’ test has shortened investment horizons
Macoun echoes AustralianSuper Chair Don Russell’s view that the performance test has outlived its usefulness and is now harming good investing. Because the bulk of the rolling timeframe is already locked in, super funds are forced into short-term decision-making.
“It’s shortened the time horizon because even though notionally it’s a 10-year test, the first nine years have already... we’ve already got the outcomes of that. So people are very focused on just the last year. That’s too short a timeframe for good investing.”
#4: Industry consolidation sacrifices performance for scale
As traditional fund managers merge to chase scale, Macoun argues they are destroying the exact boutique culture required to generate alpha. He believes the need for the multi-affiliate model is greater today than when he started.
“In the pursuit of scale, and you need scale in distribution and ops, the non-investment functions, they’re giving up the environment where investment excellence can be undertaken. I would never sacrifice the investment environment for scale.”
#5: Private credit’s current rough patch is a healthy shakeout
Despite recent headlines questioning the Australian private credit sector, Macoun views the current challenges as a temporary pause rather than a structural derailment. Rising rates and real estate headwinds are separating the skilled operators from the opportunists.
“We always said there’s a cycle to credit and there’ll be a period where it’s more challenged. We think that will have the benefit of sorting out who are good. And there are some players, I think, who are not good enough who’ve come into a rapidly growing market.”
#6: Offshore markets are now Pinnacle’s biggest growth engine
Pinnacle has successfully exported its model overseas, starting with UK distribution before backing London-based startups like Life Cycle and acquiring a 100% stake in UK multi-affiliate platform Pacific Asset Management. For the first time, offshore net inflows outpaced both Australian retail and Australian institutional channels last year.
“About a third of our funds are from overseas-based investors now in 50 countries. It’s growing rapidly. We can continue to be a very major player in Australia, but we’ll probably grow even faster overseas than in Australia.”
#7: Don’t start a business just to make money
Reflecting on navigating the GFC just two years after founding Pinnacle, when short-selling bans temporarily wiped out affiliate Plato’s entire proposition, Macoun says conviction and resilience are the only things that get founders through.
“Don’t even think about it unless you are completely convinced with all of your heart that you’ve got something that there’s a huge need for. If people set out and think, ‘Oh, I can make a lot of money,’ they’ll almost certainly fail because they’ll try to take shortcuts, they’ll give up.”
1 stock mentioned