What Mattered Today

James Gerrish

Market Matters

The market opened with a flurry of selling this morning  as news broke that the banks had collectively written to the PM somewhat surprisingly requesting an in-depth banking enquiry in a move designed to end speculation and reduce the ongoing rot of public and political opinion. The response, which I think is a very good one from the banks, reminds me of a quote I had written on my desk a few years ago – seems relevant here - You can’t control everything that happens to you, but you can control the way you respond - and in your response is your greatest power.

Banks have clearly gotten on the front foot here, sick of being up against the ropes and the response here is clearly a strong one. The emotional reaction on the market first up was to SELL, before cooler heads prevailed and the majority of the banks actually finished in the black after being down substantially early on. It seems to me, the banks have been preparing for this for some time and a Royal Commission has a couple of important aspects that work in their favour.

The points of reference are more concise and the process more structured versus the huge number of independent enquires that are underway, while the commission will be conducted under a tight time frame, which will bring closure to a situation that has continued to drag. As was stated in the media today, this is the least worst option from a list of bad outcomes for the banks.  Important to say though, that banks have clearly had issues in the past, and given their size and complexity, will probably have issues in the future. We doubt a Govt enquiry will achieve a lot in a practical sense however, we’ve now sorted the same sex marriage debate, the dual citizenship saga continues but has an endpoint it would seem, and now we have a timeframe to get banks from headlining the political agenda – prompts the obvious question - what will the Politicians do once these issues are sorted? I have a few suggestions….  

Elsewhere, some huge volatility in Aristocrat Leisure which reported full year results this morning  + announced the purchase of an online gambling business for around $1bn – the stock the was up initially before falling off the proverbial cliff shortly after. We held ALL and had a $24 price target, and fortunately exited above $24 however, time was of the essence in that trade. More on this stock below + our views for those that may have missed the exit.    

On the mkt today, sellers were dominate early and targeted the banks obviously,  however the low was put in at 11am and the index grinded higher from there - a range today of +/-  54 points, a high of 6003, a low of 5949 and a close of 5969,   off -41pts or -0.69%.

ASX 200 Intra-Day Chart

ASX 200 Daily Chart


1.Banks  - to give some context here around the performances today, the knee jerk reaction happened straight up on open after the enquiry was announced, but the majority traded to lows mid-morning before recovering, Westpac the biggest recovery adding +2.18% from the lows while ANZ bounced, but was more of a whimper. We used the weakness this morning to top up on CBA in the Platinum Portfolio.

Westpac Daily Chart

2. Retailers  – News today that OrotonGroup had collapsed after major shareholders the Lane family and high profile fund manager Will Vicars failed to step in and rescue the business. They had tipped in funds earlier in the year, and were not willing to do so again. This is a company that has been in a death spiral for some time as they struggled to extract sales from what was a very strong brand. Looking at their FY17  financial metrics, top line was OK but down on prior years, however when rent is 20% of sales and your operating on EBITDA margins are just 2%, something has to give. Today it did and administrators were appointed

OrotonGroup Monthly Chart  

Elsewhere in retail land, there was actually some love back in the sector led by Myer which rallied +6.08% to finish at 78.5c – SL and MM will be waving the flag today, while strong buying was across the board – mainly early on in JB Hi Fi (JBH) and Harvey Norman (HV) which having been tracking higher of late despite the negative headlines…   

Harvey Norman Daily Chart   

4. Aristocrat Leisure (ALL) – I haven’t seen volatility like that in such a short window for a while with the stock reporting FY results around 9.00am and announcing an acquisition of Big Fish Games for around $1bn at that time. The open was strong on the mkt (+3%) before getting clobbered by around 12% as what looked like one big line of aggressive selling that simply whacked the stock. The result in my view was decent, the acquisition stacks up, but clearly the increased gearing has spooked a few – or simply we’ve seen some decent profit taking.

Aristocrat Intra-Day Chart

Aristocrat Daily Chart

5. Fortescue Metals (FMG) – a big change in terms of leadership announced today and the stock reacted reasonably well, closing down just 2c to $4.60. I say reasonably well given there were a few obvious surprises in the re-shuffle. Firstly, we now see a female CEO leading an Iron Ore venture which is clearly not the norm, with Elizabeth Gaines stepping up from CFO into the CEO role. Probably not the mkts first choice however she’s very well respected and has a very good financial mind. Supporting here is the operational guru Greg Lilleyman, the current director of operations (ex RIO)  who many thought would be the next CEO. A new CFO and Deputy CEO also announced, however the key takeout here, is that appointing a ‘finance type’ to the role shows how far FMG has come, and its likely path into the future. The heavy lifting in terms of operational efficiencies has been done, now to drive financial returns for shareholders  -  We bought FMG on Tuesday at $4.60

Fortescue Metals Daily Chart

FREE TRIAL - 14-days free stock market advice - all our reports including every ASX buy & sell recommendation - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Have a great night James & The Market Matters Team

Market Matters Disclaimer Prices as at 30/11/2017


Portfolio Manager
Market Matters

James is Portfolio Manager & Primary Author at Market Matters, a daily investment report with over 2500 subscribers that offers real market insight. He is also Senior Portfolio Manager within Shaw and Partners heading up a team that manages...

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.