One midcap that passed our ten-point checklist

The most effective way to generate new stock ideas is to be relentless. Relentless in talking with advisers and other investors, relentless in what you read, relentless in meeting with management, and relentless in developing sources for new ideas such as forums, conferences, newsletters, economic commentary, trade publications and quant screens. As John Maynard Keynes wrote: ‘The game of professional investing, is intolerably boring and over-exacting to anyone who is not entirely exempt from the gambling instinct.’ Of the above, if pushed to highlight one area that has provided the highest likelihood of success, it would be developing a wide network of quality advisers. Ultimately we still have to put every idea through our internal selection process and needless to say, we will never abdicate the decision-making component. But an experienced adviser/broker/analyst who understands the nuances of the market, can provide the best ideas with the highest likelihood of success by applying their own time, logic, experience and filters.
Romano Sala Tenna

Katana Asset Management


However a word of warning: all investors are impacted (to varying degrees) by the views of others, so just as it is important to filter out bad ideas early in the process, it is even more important to be vigilant in filtering out ‘bad’ advisers.


The vast majority of investment ideas are quickly filtered by some relatively apparent impediment, such as an inherently dangerous balance sheet, poor valuation metrics or a terminal business model. This high level but rapid assessment is critical in eliminating ideas early in the process, to enable the majority of time to be spent on the better prospects. The handful of ideas that survive, then move into the Investment Process proper.  Every investment idea at Katana is mandatorily assessed and rated on 10 criteria:


  1. Management  & Organisational Culture (also ‘Corporate Culture’)
  2. Business model  (short-medium term advantage) & Competitive Advantage (medium-long term advantage)
  3. Valuation metrics including Price Earnings Growth (PEG) ratio, Price to Earnings Ratio (PER) and dividend yield
  4. Macro and sector outlook
  5. Appropriate price action; we seek to move ‘in harmony’ with the greater market and in this respect technical analysis provides insights into investor sentiment
  6. Strong balance sheet, indicating safety, prudent management and flexibility
  7. Quality of Earnings (6 key assessments)
  8. High Operating Cash Flow (OCF)  & High Free Cash Flow (FCF)
  9. Return on Equity (ROE), Return on Price Equity (ROPE) & Return on Assets (ROA) ~ to assess effect of gearing on ROE
  10. Liquidity and Size.

Premier Investments Limited (PMV) is the most recent investment addition to our portfolios. Of the ten key criteria that we mandatorily assess, none is more important than management and more difficult to assess or qualitative in nature. In the case of PMV, we see arguably the best and most successful retail team in Australia, headed by industry veteran Solomon Lew. Furthermore, we see an extraordinary alignment of interests, with the key staff owning approximately 42% of stock on issue.


PMV also boasts an attractive valuation, which is ostensibly underpinned by double-digit earnings per share growth over our 3 year forecast period.  PMV scores well in respect to operating cashflow and also quality of earnings, which can prove problematic for retail stocks.  Return on equity and liquidity are also both reasonable. And given our pre-disposition with capital preservation, the balance sheet is essential to every investment thesis. PMV rates highly in this regard, with net cash approaching $200m plus circa $300m in Breville Group Limited (BRG) stock.

For more articles from Katana, click here:  (VIEW LINK)

2 stocks mentioned

Romano  Sala Tenna
Portfolio Manager
Katana Asset Management

Katana Asset Management was founded in September 2003 as a boutique investment management firm. Katana employs an all opportunity investment mandate being style, sector and market cap agnostic.

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.


Sign In or Join Free to comment