The stable breeding contrarian winners
Please note this was filmed on 12 November 2026.
There are plenty of macro distractions for investors to get their teeth stuck into right now, says Allan Gray portfolio manager Tim Hillier.
"You can draw this fairly clean line through the fact that there's a couple of wars in Europe and in the Middle East," he says. "Commodity prices are high, you're seeing inflation rising and reserve banks are raising interest rates. The consumer's getting squeezed. So there's a lot of factors there that impact the near-term earnings for a company."
But those distractions are exactly that, says Hillier, and for contrarian investors like Allan Gray, what's more important is being able to cut through to what's important.
"If we as investors start getting caught up in all that noise, we're going to just spin in circles. We try to look through all that noise and focus on what we think the long-term fundamentals are for a business."
In this interview, Hillier explains what it's like being a contrarian investor in the current environment, his biggest contrarian mistake and what it taught him about assessing stocks, and the unloved ASX companies he likes the look of now.
Being a contrarian in contrary times
It feels like market noise has continued to ratchet up in recent times, but Hillier says what also makes it an interesting, and opportune, time for contrarian investing is the rise of passive and index-aware investing and how it's impacting markets.
"When that was a small part of the market, it was a very successful strategy for a lot of people, but you have to wonder as that becomes larger, whether or not the tail gets so big, it starts to wag the dog," he says.
The other development is how many investors are trading on sentiment instead of fundamentals, and the impact that is also having on valuations.
"Certainly something I see is what I call the rise of narrative investing. A lot of investors seem to tell you about their investment case solely based on how great a company is and the fantastic things it's doing and the great product it has without much else attached to that."
"When a company starts doing well and the share price starts to go up and it's got some tailwinds, you'd be surprised just how much investors will be prepared to pay to invest in a company."
He tells the story of a recent hiking trip to Moraine Lake in Canada, where popular photo spots are overrun by tourists. But if you move off the normal path, you can find equally beautiful photo spots where there's no one to be seen. That's how he sees contrarian investing.
"Our job is to take that other path," Hillier says. "In this case, the walk's quite easy, but in reality, the path is sometimes a bit more challenging. But it's to get to that spot where there is no one, because we often think that's where the best opportunities are to be found."
"If every second investor is taking a selfie with a hot stock, it's unlikely you're going to be able to buy that at an attractive price."
His biggest mistake
And the nature of being a contrarian investor means things aren't always going to go to plan. For Hillier, there's one call that stands out.
"Probably the biggest mistake I've made while I've been at Allan Gray was getting us into AMP."
"We did that at a time when the business clearly had a set of challenges. It was around the time of the Royal Commission, but we thought that the price adequately compensated us for those risks. We thought there'd be a reasonable tail of earnings and there was a lot of capital in the business - real capital, real assets that we though could be liberated in time."
"It didn't go to plan. Some of the things that went wrong were hard to anticipate."
A sexual harassment complaint against a senior executive at AMP Capital led to the collapse of that business, and the sale of its life insurance business at what Hillier considered to be the bottom of the cycle also contributed to AMP's woes.
"But most of the mistakes in that case were our own," he says. "We should have foreseen that things would deteriorate quicker than they did."
The biggest takeaway was in how he should assess the value offered by a company's services.
"The cost of turning around these challenged companies can be higher than you expect to, so we've learned the lesson there," he says. "If I see a company now and I think that its customers are not getting a good deal in the products that they're buying from a company, as AMP's clients were going back to 2018-2019, I think you have to be very cautious about the durability of an earning stream."
A contrarian's ASX stock picks
The Allan Gray Australia Stable Fund looks to beat cash but with lower volatility than the Australian sharemarket by allocating up to 50% of the fund in Australian equities alongside cash, term deposits and government bonds.
But given how yields have grown recently, the landscape for the fund has shifted, and so has its approach.
"The market is on a forward multiple of 18 to 19 times at the moment," says Hillier. "And if you invert that, it gives you an earnings yield of 5%. Bonds are also on about 5% yields today. Now those things aren't the same, but it's been a really long time, about 15 to 20 years since fixed income yields were near the yield that you get in the market."
"We think that's quite compelling and it certainly raises the bar for investing in equities today."
Historically, the fund has maintained around a 25% allocation to Australian equities. Right now, that is closer to 16%. But that small equity allocation remains one of the key alpha drivers for the fund, and as such, getting the stock selection right is more crucial than ever.
Two notable current holdings are Orora Ltd (ASX: ORA) and Endeavour (ASX: EDV), both relatively unloved by the market but which Hillier says are now trading at attractive discounts.
The first, can and bottle producer Orora, has endured a "torrid time" recently, he says.
"The industry in general is characterised by oversupply," says Hillier. "They've had cost inflation and they've also made some of their own problems. They acquired a company called SaverGlass for $2 billion and seem to have paid well over the odds for that business."
"And as a result, Orora has really been hammered, but we think the investment case today is very compelling. You pay about 12 to 13 times forward earnings for that business, and we think earnings aren't particularly high at the moment."
With Orora now valued around $2 billion, the $2 billion or so it paid for SaverGlass means you're effectively getting two companies for the price of one, says Hillier.
"You're either buying Orora or you're buying SaverGlass and you get the other one for free. It's never quite that simple, but that's another way to look at the investment. We think the upside downside skew from here is very attractive."
The other contrarian pick is Endeavour Group, which Hillier says has endured some of the same dynamics as Orora.
"They've also suffered from a lack of volume growth in the industry and extra competition that's come from that," he says. "So margins are relatively low. It was spun out of Woolworths several years ago and has been a serial underperformer since then."
Having fallen out of favour with the market, it now trades at a much more attractive valuation to other well-regarded consumer names.
"Today you pay about 15 to 16 times forward earnings for Endeavour. It's not necessarily a particularly low multiple, but it wasn't long ago that Endeavour's main retail brand, Dan Murphy's, was considered one of the highest regarded retail brands in Australia. right up there with Woolworths, which it was spun out of.
"Woolworths trades on a PE of in the mid 20s, so we think that's a very attractive discount as well."

2 topics
2 stocks mentioned
1 fund mentioned
1 contributor mentioned