Even before the COVID-19 pandemic rocked global financial markets, Australia was on its way to join the lower yield world. Now, Australian investors in search of stable, current income strategies are facing a challenge as strategies of the past are unlikely to generate the returns and levels of income they once provided.
This can be observed across the risk spectrum with the Reserve Bank of Australia’s (the “RBA”) cash rate at 0.25% and Australian government bond yields below 1%, all the way up the risk spectrum to Australian banks’ equity and their now more uncertain dividends.
We believe solutions to generate higher income and diversification for Australian investors’ portfolios exist within certain parts of the global fixed income markets that provide current income and attractive relative yields with downside protection; we call it the “sweet spot” of credit.
To be successful in what we call the “sweet spot,” we believe an arduous focus on capital preservation and the flexibility to select the most attractive relative value are key. We believe this can be achieved via our ability to identify attractive relative value in the more senior, higher quality segments of the bond, loan and structured credit markets and shift allocations among these asset classes as appropriate. In addition to maintaining a well-diversified portfolio of senior debt, a 50% allocation to investment grade credit further strengthens the high-quality nature of the strategy.
The Challenge – Australia Joins the Low Yield World
Until recently, Australian investors didn’t have to look too far for attractive yields and income, but the last 24 months have accelerated Australia’s participation in the low cash rate and bond yield world.
According to a report published by the ASX in 2018, in the last 20 years through December 2017, Australian cash annualised gross return was 4.6% p.a. Interestingly, cash returned 3.6% p.a. in the last 10 years through December 2017, which suggests a downward trajectory of the RBA target cash rate and term deposit rates (Chart 1).
With the target RBA cash rate currently sitting at 0.25%, we believe that achieving the returns of the past in cash products seems unlikely for Australian investors.
Chart 1 - RBA Target Rate and 1-Year Term Deposit Rate
Source: Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA), as of May 2020.
Moving up the risk spectrum (with risk defined as asset price volatility) in the last 10 years, Australian government and corporate bonds have offered attractive yields, generating higher income and returns than cash, with the same ASX report showing returns of c. 6% p.a. for the 10 years to December 2017.
These attractive returns and levels of income have partly been due to a falling yield environment which generates capital gains in fixed rate bonds. When realised, these gains are distributed as income alongside interest payments.
As illustrated in Chart 2 below, over the last 10 years to March 2020, Australian 10-year government bond yields went from over 5% to below 1%, and in the last 12 months, from over 1.5% in March 2019 to below 1%. This latest drop has driven strong returns and provided the expected counterbalance to riskier assets such as equity in such periods of volatility.
However, looking ahead, with 98% of Australia government bonds currently trading at or above 100% of face value and little room for yields to move further down (although they could go negative!), we believe income generation and outsized returns are unlikely to be what investors have experienced in recent periods.
Chart 2 - Australia 10-Year Bond Yield
Source: Bloomberg, as of 22 May 2020.
Finally, moving all the way up the risk spectrum to equities, Australian investors have enjoyed many years of high and dependable dividend payments from the major Australian banks. For those happy to endure some price volatility going up the risk spectrum, the four major Australian banks have been a reliable source of higher income.
However, in the wake of the COVID-19 crisis and the ensuing economic turmoil, an unprecedented level of uncertainty leaves many questioning the likelihood and reliability of those dividends as the banks employ a more conservative approach to cash management. As an example, NAB decided to cut their next dividend payment by 64%. NAB has not seen such low dividends since 1994; even during the Global Financial Crisis (the “GFC”), dividends did not decrease as precipitously as they have recently (Chart 3). This decision and the uncertainty around what other banks will do, has highlighted to investors that unlike fixed income and credit instruments, shares have no contractual obligation to a fixed level of distribution.
Chart 3 - National Australia Bank (NAB) Dividend Rate per Share (AUD)
Source: National Australia Bank (NAB), as of May 2020.
The “Sweet Spot” of Credit
The challenge posed by low yields is not new for many global investors. Since 2007, the Ares Credit Group has been able to diversify portfolios with asset classes that we believe offer attractive yields and current income within global fixed income markets. We call it the “sweet spot” of credit.
We believe high quality corporate and structured credit presents the most compelling risk-reward opportunity.
Our strategy seeks to avoid riskier asset classes (equities) as well as minimizes exposure to the more stressed, lower quality segments of the credit market (CCC-rated bonds and loans), which reduces volatility and default risk, and further takes advantage of the downside protection offered by senior and often secured credit position in the capital structure of corporate bonds and loans and asset backed securities. In tandem, Ares believes this particular focus offers greater opportunities for current income in yield than traditional fixed income and passive strategies.
Chart 4 - The “Sweet Spot” of Credit
Within global fixed income specifically, falling yields accelerated by the recent sell-off in risky assets resulted in past performance favouring higher interest rate duration assets (Chart 5). For example, U.S. government bonds and high-grade corporate bonds that have higher interest rate duration risk than bank loans or investment grade CLO debt have outperformed (higher return and lower volatility). But, with government bond yields at or close to historical lows, the potential return and current income generation from the lower end of the risk spectrum seems challenged.
Chart 5 - Bloomberg Barclays Global-Aggregate Index (Unhedged US$) Yield Versus Duration
Source: Bloomberg, of April 30, 2020. Please refer to pages 9-11 for Index Definitions and an important index disclosure.
Our focus is therefore on the asset classes that currently offer higher relative yields. These higher yields are largely derived from the credit spreads these securities pay on top of government bond yields. These spreads compensate investors for the additional risk that they take by investing in credit. As of the date of this letter, credit spreads in bank loans and corporate bonds are wide by historical standards, partly due to elevated fears around default risk for credit instruments and uncertainty in general which has pressured technicals. We believe this environment presents ample opportunity for managers looking to take advantage of inefficiently priced segments of the fixed income markets. And, while dynamic allocation across asset classes is certainly a distinctive feature of Ares’ strategy, we recognize that falling yields is a global trend across developed and emerging markets and seek to opportunistically allocate across regions.
Chart 6 - Relative Yields Across Asset Classes
Source: ICE BofA Indices, S&P Capital IQ, Credit Suisse Leveraged Loan Index, JPM CLOIE Indices, as of May 20, 2020.
In other words, current income and potential returns are attractive in the sweet spot of credit, but to fully optimise the strategy, we believe managers must be focused on minimising default risk.
Protecting the Downside
While outperformance is certainly a key component of successful investing, as a steward of investor capital, Ares places an equally important emphasis on downside protection and capital preservation. A heightened focus on portfolio positioning, volatility and duration are of particular importance during times of stress and economic uncertainty.
Default risk analysis is fully incorporated into Ares’ investment process, which employs rigorous monitoring of credit performance with the robust use of data analytics to identify potential downgrade candidates. This focus has resulted in Ares experiencing significantly lower defaults in its broadly syndicated bank loan and high yield bond strategies since inception during times of stress. At the height of the GFC fall-out in 2009, U.S. high yield bond and loan markets saw default rates rise close to 11% and 15%, respectively, while Ares’ flagship bank loan fund and U.S. High Yield composite have experienced fewer than 4%. Ares’ European portfolios performed similarly, with its flagship European high yield portfolios experiencing a 3.4% default rate during the GFC versus the market’s 13%. During the same period, Ares’ flagship European loans portfolios experienced 0 defaults.
Independent of the fund’s 50% allocation to investment grade credit, Ares expects to maintain a higher concentration of double B-rated loans and bonds and will opportunistically consider single B-rated debt with strong fundamentals and the potential for upside. In current market conditions, we believe our ability to significantly under-default the market will again prove critical to capitalising on opportunities available in the sweet spot of credit.
The Opportunity Set Has Broadened Amidst Uncertainty, Volatility and Bifurcation in the Credit Markets
Our investment process places a strong emphasis on relative value analyses to identify optimal risk-adjusted investment opportunities. In this uncertain, volatile and bifurcated environment our process has highlighted the following opportunities within the sweet spot of credit.
Volatility and uncertainty around corporate defaults have pushed credit spreads (Option Adjusted Spreads or “OAS”) in the high yield bond market (“HY”) to levels not seen since 2009. As it has become increasingly rare to see spreads widen past 800 bps, it is interesting to note that HY OAS have only been wider than 600 – 800 bps c. 20% of the time since 1996.
Additionally, when loan and high yield spreads widen past 800 bps, if they were to return to their historical averages in the next 12 or 24 months, potential returns in that space may be significant as illustrated below.
Chart 7 - Forward Returns When Loan Spreads Are Between 600-800 bps
Chart 8 - Median 24M Forward Return Potential vs Frequency
Alternative credit provides multiple ways to find value and protection in different market conditions. CLO Debt in particular has consistently provided a premium to corporate yields across rating classes, ranging from 3.5% for single-A tranches to 9.3% for double-B rated tranches. Most recently, shorter-dated, de-levering deals that have substantial loss protection have been attractive, and we are also starting to see strong value in clean, post-COVID-19 issuance. Regardless of the market environment, the Ares approach to investing with full transparency to the underlying assets allows for the ability to sift through a variety of available investment opportunities to find the assets that best provide the combination of current income with loss protection, which we can combine with loans and bonds to build a portfolio that meets our investors’ needs.
We believe the “sweet spot of credit,” comprised of corporate and structured markets, offers a compelling opportunity for Australian investors seeking diversification and stable current income in varied market environments. To be successful in the so-called “sweet spot,” we believe an arduous focus on capital preservation and the flexibility to select the most attractive relative value are key.
We believe nimble and flexible style of portfolio management with the ability to dynamically allocate across asset classes when shifts in relative value occur is important.
Further, we believe the ability to identify and unlock value especially in currently volatile and bifurcated markets is a strength. Finally, with capital preservation as a key characteristic of the strategy, managers should be intently focused on finding those opportunities with optimal downside protection and lower volatility.
Looking for alternative income?
Ares takes both a bottom-up and top-down approach, with a deep focus on disciplined credit selection and active asset rotation, as well as current, and forward looking global macroeconomic and technical factors impacting each sector. For more information, fill in the contact form below, or visit our website to learn more.