Uncertain times and extraordinary markets

Michael Skinner

Renaissance Asset Management

As the world grapples with COVID-19 and the worst economic downtown since the Great Depression, global stock markets surpass all-time highs. These conflicting outcomes are cause for both contemplation and caution.

Warren Buffett reminds us that "risk comes from not knowing what you're doing", this message has never been so important.

Nobody knows what is going to happen next.

There is simply no precedent to the major events playing out across the world. There is so much uncertainty, that quantifying the collective impact on financial markets is impossible. In the last 12 months alone, we have experienced: devastating bushfires, the on-going COVID-19 pandemic, an oil price war, the ‘Black Lives Matter’ protests, a global recession, record unemployment, unequalled monetary and fiscal policy, and extreme volatility across currency, debt and equity markets.

Uncertainty is at a peak.

And an uncertain world is the worst possible environment for financial investment. It becomes very difficult, if not impossible, to quantify risk.  

Yet recently we have witnessed widespread risk taking by those unaware of uncertainty’s danger. This is occurring with ever increasing vigour as financial markets dislocate away from fundamentals.

In the last 3 months alone, I have had countless people ask me "how to buy shares". I have heard of ‘financial advisors’ advocating for superannuation withdrawal so that clients can ‘start trading’ (on margin!). And I have had numerous people ask me if they should buy Tesla, Afterpay or Amazon shares as "valuation does not matter in today’s globalised world".

Not one of these people have mentioned price, valuation or risk. In many cases, they don’t even know the stock code to purchase the security. I don’t write this to criticise, I write this to provide insight into how the market is accounting for risk. And today, it frequently isn’t.

As a result, volatility and unpredictably has drastically increased. In March due to Covid-19, we experienced the fastest and deepest stock market fall in history, greater than 40%.

This was followed by an aggressive recovery as over $20 trillion dollars was committed globally to combat the virus’s economic impact.

Never before have governments acted so quickly to provide support to the global economy. This fact, coupled with a decade of declining interest rates has elevated sovereign, corporate and personal debt to extreme levels. The world has not experienced a confluence of events such as these, the impact on our economic system has never been tested.

Ric Kayne famously said that "95% of all financial history happens within two standard deviations of normal, and everything interesting happens outside of two standard deviations". We are now operating many standard deviations away from normal, and strange things are starting to happen.

  • Global markets surpass all-time highs as unemployment skyrockets and businesses face widespread insolvency. The NASDAQ is now 10% above its pre-COVID-19 levels and the Chinese market 12% above.
  • Government bond yields have turned negative, -0.50% pa in Switzerland. Just to be clear, this is not supposed to happen. Society is literally paying banks to hold their money.
  • The US Federal Reserve is buying junk bonds (the debt of failing companies) for this first time in history.
  • Hertz, a company in bankruptcy (essentially worthless) has people wanting to buy $1bn worth of its stock.
  • Tesla, a company that makes zero profit, is now worth more than Toyota. In fact, Tesla is worth more than Ford and General Motors combined, despite delivering less than one-tenth of the vehicle sales in 2019.
  • Internet day traders blindly pick stocks from scrabble bags and amass millions of followers.
  • And, online trading platforms promote and gamify day trading. The Robinhood platform for example, utilises falling confetti to celebrate each new buy transaction.

These events are not normal.

The greatest investors of our time are now sounding the alarm, yet many of us are not listening. Warren Buffet holds more than US$130b in cash reserves and continues to highlight the importance of holding cash in a crisis. Jeremy Grantham of investment giant GMO believes we may be experiencing the "fourth major stock market bubble" in his 40+ year career. And Howard Marks of Oaktree Capital talks to significant global uncertainty in his 2020 series of memos, he also questions the veracity of the current share market recovery.

These investing greats are not calling the next bear market, nor another decade long bull run. They know better than to forecast the madness of markets. Rather, they counsel the need for caution given vast and complex global uncertainty.

Australians should to pay heed to this advice and realise that financial markets today are no place for wide-spread speculation.

The eloquent wisdom of Charlie Munger is well suited to our current age, he reminds us that “nobody knows what’s going to happen”. So perhaps we should all stop trying to predict the unpredictable.

These are uncertain times and extraordinary markets.

*This article was originally published by The Australian Newspaper.

About Michael

Michael Skinner is a portfolio manager at Renaissance Asset Management. He also lectures in finance and engineering for the University of NSW and is a honours supervisor at the University of Adelaide.

Hit the 'follow' button below to receive future articles about investing, economics and sustainability. 

Never miss an update

Stay up to date with my content by hitting the 'follow' button below and you'll be notified every time I post a wire. Not already a Livewire member? Sign up today to get free access to investment ideas and strategies from Australia's leading investors.

Portfolio Manager
Renaissance Asset Management

Michael is a Portfolio Manager at Renaissance overseeing Australian equity investments. He also is a Finance Lecturer at UNSW and a Honours Supervisor at the University of Adelaide. Michael holds a BEng, GDipLaw, MBA and a MLaw.

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.