What Mattered Today; Signs of a short term top

James Gerrish

Market Matters

Another day that saw the best of things early on with the market trading up in the morning session before some tepid – subdued profit taking unfolded later on. Some good economic data out today with November Building Approvals shooting the lights out printing +11.7% v forecasts of -1.3% while the Roy Morgan gauge of Consumer Confidence was also strong…

The good read on the consumer prompted more buying in the recently beaten up retailers and that was amplified by an earnings upgrade from Noni B showing that some retailers are actually doing pretty well! Overall, strength in the Iron Ore and Oil price overnight saw the material stocks lead the charge today – BHP up another 1.67% to close at $31.06 while Fortescue put on 8c to close at $5.31. We sold that one too early! Overall the Material stocks added +0.96% while the weakest link was the Health care sector which fell by -0.86%.  We had a very tight overall range today of +/-  14 points, a high of 6149, a low of 6135 and a close of 6135,  up 5pts or +0.09%

ASX 200 Intra-Day Chart – morning optimism sold into  

ASX 200 Daily Chart – tight ranges, and market finishing well off highs – suggests our mkt is exhausted – pullback imminent


1. QBE Insurance (QBE) $10.54 / -1.77%; A bearish broker note out from Macquarie on the stock prompted selling today with the silver donut suggesting that with a new Group CEO and CFO, they’re likely to ‘tweak’ long term margin guidance which when you think about it – it’s not a bad call given they’ve missed their combined operating ratio target 7 times from the last 10 attempts! They go onto say that bond yields haven’t ticked up enough, and even though the insurance cycle is turning, momentum remains slow and those factors won’t be enough to offset the tweak in margin guidance. They had the stock on outperform - which is a BUY and now downgrade to neutral – which is a HOLD. We own the stock, have watched our strong profitable position evaporate into a breakeven position and are starting to lose some patience with it. In short, the macro backdrop is very supported and will continue to improve and we thought that that internal issues were being sorted however it  seems the business still has some near term risk. I’m reticent to follow Macquarie but this is a stock we’re pondering as a SELL. Perhaps it’s just too big of a leveraged beast – has too many moving parts and is simply too hard at the moment. We hold QBE in the Platinum Portfolio

QBE Daily Chart

2. Nick Scali (NCK) $7.05 / 4.44 %; a combination of a good consumer confidence read and positive sentiment from Noni B who became the second retailer to upgrade this year with first-half sales were up 3% on a like-for-like basis –Nick Scali was bid up today around 4% and importantly, pushing back up through the $7 region to close near it’s $7.08 highs. Good retailers perform in most environments and we own NCK because it’s quality and has an exceptionally strong track record. We also own Harvey Norman however it’s not the quality business that NCK is – however stacks up in terms of valuation. We hold NCK in the Income Portfolio

Nick Scali Daily Chart

3. Retail Food Group (RFG)  $2.32 / -6.07%; You wouldn’t believe it however RFG have downgraded earnings guidance again to less than the $22.0m advised on 19 December. The revision was caused by the timing of payments due from a new franchise arrangement. Although the payments are still expected, the market didn’t go easy on RFG, closing down 6% on the day – which was up from session lows however you’ve simply got to be concerned about whether or not management have a handle on this business. Clearly they have completely misread franchisee sentiment which has lead to public dispute and a big rout in share price while their disclosure to the market has been perplexing, with todays downgrade simply adding more kindling to the raging fire… We do not hold RFG

Retail Food Group Daily Chart


Have a great night

James & the Market Matters Team

Market Matters Disclaimer

Prices as at 09/01/18

3 stocks mentioned

James Gerrish
Portfolio Manager
Market Matters

James is the Lead Portfolio Manager & primary author at Market Matters, a digital advice & investment platform with over 2500 members that offers real market intel & portfolios open for investment. He is also a Senior Portfolio Manager at Shaw and...

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.


Sign In or Join Free to comment