In Extremis

Tracey McNaughton

Escala Partners

2020 was a year of extremes. The COVID crisis took the world’s economic, financial and social infrastructure to the limit. Economies fell into a deep recession. Financial markets were sent into a tail-spin drawing governments and central banks into action like never before. And while our hospitals were overflowing our cities were empty. What does the world look like after such a year?

Perversely, we expect 2021 to be exceptionally strong. Economies and financial markets were taken to their extremes by an event that for the most part will be addressed by vaccine development. The global recession will be remembered as the deepest, but shortest recession on record.

Given this, we expect small cap companies, cyclical sectors and emerging markets to outperform in 2021. In particular, we expect the Asian region to benefit the most. While 165 countries fell into recession in 2020, China was not one of them.

While economies and financial markets will snap back in 2021, the year of extremities will leave its mark. The Global Financial Crisis (GFC) in 2008 had already pushed the world into the “New Normal” - lower interest rates, lower inflation and lower economic growth. The 2020 policy response will take us even further in that direction.

Source: Bloomberg

We are now entering the “New-New Normal”. Cyclically, we are expecting an economic recovery in 2021. Structurally, however, we remain in a lower for much longer environment. The Japanese experience offers valuable lessons. A loose monetary policy can stabilize a recession for the short term, but a persistent flood of cheap money paralyzes productivity gains and growth. This means investors need to look further and think smarter to achieve target returns.

How the year of extremes will shape the future

1. Extreme fiscal debt

Most recessions are caused by excessive tightening of monetary policy that hits household and corporate balance sheets hard. Subsequent balance sheet repair retards the recovery process. The 2009 recession in the US was a drawn-out affair because of this.

To quote Paul Keating, the recession we had in 2020 was “a recession we had to have”. But not for the usual reasons. Interest rates were not lifted to 17.5% as they were in 1990. Inflation wasn’t running at 10%. The recession in 2020 was caused by the closing of the economy to deal with a health crisis. There was nothing economic or financial about it. There were economic and financial consequences of course but for the first time since the Spanish flu, the global economy was in recession literally for health reasons. Quite unusually, government balance sheets were hit the hardest in this recession. Household balance sheets actually improved thanks to the substantial size of government handouts.

Source: Bloomberg

With the health crisis now (largely) dealt with, economies can soon start to re-open again. This re-opening will be super-charged by the sheer size of government stimulus and the fact that household and corporate balance sheets were for the most part insulated.

Where the damage has been done, on government balance sheets, the repair will take years. But because it is government, the hard work can be delayed until the economy is firmly back on its feet.

2. Extreme market intervention

Source: Bloomberg

Unconventional monetary policy rapidly became conventional in 2020. No fewer than 30 central banks around the world are now competing with ordinary investors to buy bonds in the secondary market.

This is having at least three effects. First, as central bank ownership increases, turnover and liquidity in the market decreases. The central banks in Japan and Europe now own 40-50% of their respective markets. 

The Japanese bond market now barely exists. Days go by without a single trade. Some months see only a handful of trades.

The second effect is a crowding-out of investors for attractive risk-adjusted returns. Returns are defined by their risk. Where there is less risk, there is less return. Where there is less return, there is less consumption. Bonds in Japan are regularly issued with a coupon of just 0.1%. For some private-sector employees, this coupon is also the rate of return on their pension savings - one reason, perhaps, that many Japanese are so reluctant to spend.

The third effect is the impairment of price discovery. The share price of Hertz should not have surged by 896% following its filing for bankruptcy in May 2020 but it did because the US Federal Reserve was a buyer of its bonds. 

Central bank buying of bonds causes risk to be mis-priced, weakening the link between risk and reward.  

3. Extremely low inflation

While the volume of money in the economy has surged, the speed at which it circulates has collapsed. This has put downward pressure on inflation and hence interest rates. Growing income inequality is playing a role here. The upper strata of wealthy households spend a far smaller percentage of their income than the less wealthy. An increase in inequality correlates with a slower velocity of money. 

The very policies used to address the effects of the pandemic have led to a rise in inequality, contributing to a decline in velocity and stymieing inflation. As was the case following the GFC, policymakers protected Wall St much better than they protected Main St.

Source: Bloomberg

Three investment implications that stem from this are:

  1. Near term tactical (6-12mths): We favour small-cap companies, cyclical sectors and emerging markets
  2. Medium-term tactical (12-18mths): We still prefer growth sectors and markets over value
  3. Medium-term strategic (5-years): Increase allocation to private markets to avoid central bank crowding-out.

Not already a Livewire member?

Sign up today to get free access to investment ideas and strategies from Australia’s leading investors.

Escala Partners Pty Ltd (EPPL) (ACN 155 884 236) is a Corporate Authorised Representative of Escala Wealth Management Pty Ltd ((EWM) ACN: 162 573 828) holder of AFSL 456207. EWM is 100% owned by EPPL. The content of this document is general in nature only and is not personal advice. This means that it has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Thus, before any investment decision is made based on this document, an EPPL investment Advisor should be consulted or you need to consider the appropriateness of the advice having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs. We also recommend that you obtain a copy of the Product Disclosure Statement (if applicable). This document is based on information from reliable sources; no representation, warranty or undertaking is given or made in relation to the accuracy or completeness of the information presented. Any conclusions, recommendations and advice contained here in are reasonably held at the time of completion but are subject to change without notice. EPPL does not accept any responsibility to inform you of any matter that subsequently comes to its notice, which may affect any of the information contained in this document and assumes no obligation to update and reissue this document following publication. EPPL, its directors, employees and agents disclaim all liability for any errors in, or omission from, this document or for any resulting loss or damage suffered by the recipient or any other person as a consequence of relying upon this document. Historical performance is often not a reliable indicator of future performance. You should not rely solely on historical performance to make investment decisions. EPPL may receive commissions and fees from transactions involving investments referred to in this document. EPPL, its directors, employees and agents may from time to time hold interests in the securities referred to in this document. This document is a private client communication and is not intended for public circulation or for the use of any third party.

Tracey McNaughton
Chief Investment Officer
Escala Partners

Tracey was appointed Chief Investment Officer at Escala Partners in November 2019. In this role she has responsibility for strategic and tactical asset allocation and manager selection across all multi-asset funds, and is Chair of the Escala...

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.