Is Berkshire Hathaway a victim of its own success?

Tim Kelley

Montgomery Investment Management

For anyone who subscribes to the Buffet philosophy –  and that’s no small number of people – the question arises as to why this should be the case, and what it means for the ongoing success of this style of investing.  It is possible that Berkshire has experienced a difficult period in recent times, but the long time frames and apparent consistency of the decline point to lasting change, rather than something temporary.

Unfortunately, it is not easy to determine what factors might be contributing to such a change, and to what extent.  However, we can begin with a list of some of the more likely contributors, which would include the following:

  • Sheer size – it has become difficult for Berkshire to find investments that “move the needle”;
  • Markets have become more efficient over time, and therefore harder to beat; and
  • Berkshire’s investment style has become so widely adopted that it is now a “crowded” space.


There are no doubt other factors that could be proposed, but I suspect the above factors all make a meaningful contribution to the apparent decline.  We offer the following observations:

  • Size is undoubtedly part of the issue. As an investor grows in scale, the universe of meaningful investment opportunities inevitably shrinks.  This is an issue for all fund managers, and something Buffet has noted in annual letters.  Berkshire now has a market capitalisation of around US$350 billion, and even with global markets to fish in, that’s a lot of capital to deploy.
  • It seems reasonable to expect that markets do become progressively more efficient over time. Natural selection means that successful investors, practices, and innovations will attract increasing amounts of capital, while the less successful lose relevance. This is perhaps a double whammy for Berkshire because a more efficient market can be expected at the large end of town, meaning that increasing size pushes Berkshire into a more efficient and more limited investment universe and that limited universe becomes even more challenging over time.
  • Finally, there is no doubt that Berkshire’s success has spawned a great many investors looking to follow a similar path. Over long periods of time Buffet’s willingness to share his investment wisdom may be contributing to the challenge Berkshire faces. Even without this sharing of wisdom, it is likely that there would be an army of followers seeking to adopt a similar philosophy.


We can’t tell from this what the future returns from following a Buffet style investment approach might be, but there are a couple of points worth keeping in mind:

  • Scale is your enemy, and having a smaller pool of capital to deploy is a definite advantage; and
  • Simply following an approach that has worked for others is unlikely to provide a material investment ‘edge.' The Buffets of the future will probably not be those that emulate Buffet. They will be innovators who see things that others have not seen and invest in ways that others do not.


Who’s up for a challenge?

Contributed by Montgomery Investment Management:   (VIEW LINK)

Tim Kelley
Former Head of Quantitative Research
Montgomery Investment Management

Tim Kelley has retired from Montgomery Investment Management, effective 30 September 2021. Tim’s final project has been drafting our investment guidelines to integrate environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG) considerations into our...

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.