Requiem for a construction bubble

Pete Wargent

AllenWargent Property Buyers

In this report, we have isolated two of the leading indicators in Australia’s economy, namely building approvals and money growth, and highlighted some key themes arising from our findings. Our analysis is independent and takes account of evidence through liaison with industry contacts, combined with data.

In our experience, too many analysts take their cues from lagging indicators, such as the unemployment rate or inflation figures. While these figures are important, they tend to be lagging indicators and as such are of limited value when trying to anticipate future trends, generate trade themes, or make informed asset allocation decisions.

The market has generally been too positive about recently reported data. Commentary has often focused on strong employment growth, and the ongoing budget repair, which has seen the deficit narrow to the lowest level since April 2009 at just $12.1 billion or 0.7 per cent of GDP1, maintaining Australia’s AAA-rating.

However, strong employment growth in 2017 and the rolling budget deficit as taxation revenues have increased are backward-looking. Instead, we look towards trends such as jobs advertisements, which are now showing signs of softening after 17 consecutive gains and a 31 per cent increase from the cyclical nadir, and money growth which is slowing2.


7 key findings

Housing credit growth has slowed 

Housing credit growth has slowed significantly and may be expected to slow further as a result of tighter lending standards and findings arising from the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Superannuation, Banking, and Financial Services Industries (“Royal Commission”). Deposit growth and broad money growth have declined to 25½ year lows. 3


Housing market investor activity slowing 

Liaison with mortgage brokers shows that investor activity is expected to be considerably slower in H2 2018 than it was a year earlier. Major banks are at risk of losing market share to non-bank lenders and intermediaries


Dwelling prices now in decline 

Dwelling prices in Sydney are now rolling over, with Melbourne set to follow, with a potentially negative impact expected on household consumption. Dwelling prices have already been in a multi-year decline in Perth and Darwin, and Brisbane apartment prices have also declined, and significantly so in some cases


Detached house approvals robust 

Building approvals are still tracking at reasonably robust levels, especially for detached houses, driven by strong population growth and demand in Greater Melbourne and Greater Brisbane


Apartment construction to fall sharply 

We have significant evidence to show that new apartment projects are struggling to get finance approved, and therefore total residential construction is expected to slow in H2 2018. Dwellings approved but not yet commenced have already increased to the highest level on record, driven by apartment project approvals


Apartment default rising 

Liaison with industry contracts indicates that settlement defaults for some of the major developers have increased, particularly in relation to offshore buyers. The resale market is considered healthy enough at this juncture for most developers not to be materially impacted, however there is a strong likelihood that residential construction activity will now fall


Employment growth to fall 

Construction now directly employs just under 1.2 million persons in Australia, recently capturing a record high in absolute terms and, at 9.6 per cent of employment, the construction sector is at its most bloated in approximately a century4.

About ¾ of construction jobs are accounted for by the residential sector5. There is significant potential for employment growth to slow sharply over the next 12 months


Key implications and trade themes

Construction bubble 

The sector looks severely bloated, with construction employment as a share of total employment at the highest level in approximately a century.

The sector swelled through the mining boom, and even further through the apartment boom. We see this as the biggest risk for the economic outlook.

Yield curve to flatten 

Rate hike expectations should be scaled back or pushed out to at least H2 2019 or beyond


Wealth effect and construction multiplier to fade in Sydney and Melbourne 

There appears to be a danger that declining dwelling prices will negatively impact dwelling commencements, household consumption, and demand for some classes of household goods


Settlement defaults rising 

Developers are reporting rising settlement defaults. It is unclear at this stage how significant this will prove to be, but the trend should be monitored carefully


Materials demand solid but should be watched carefully

Materials companies have delivered strong returns to fund managers since Q1 2016, but exposure should be carefully monitored and managed in H2 2018 and beyond. Although a range of significant infrastructure projects should keep demand robust and detached house approvals are rising in Melbourne and Brisbane, the residential sector is set to slow significantly as the apartments pipeline shrinks


AUD downside risk:

If employment growth and the housing market slow as expected there is downside risk for the Australian dollar from US$0.755


US valuations remain stretched 

Equities valuations in the US remain at high levels, and there is a risk that tighter policy in the US sees share markets revert lower, with implications for other global stock market indices. 

You can access our full report here. 


Pete Wargent
AllenWargent Property Buyers

Co-founder of AllenWargent Property Buyers - "the better way to buy property". Veteran property market analyst & investor.

I would like to

Only to be used for sending genuine email enquiries to the Contributor. Livewire Markets Pty Ltd reserves its right to take any legal or other appropriate action in relation to misuse of this service.

Personal Information Collection Statement
Your personal information will be passed to the Contributor and/or its authorised service provider to assist the Contributor to contact you about your investment enquiry. They are required not to use your information for any other purpose. Our privacy policy explains how we store personal information and how you may access, correct or complain about the handling of personal information.


Sign In or Join Free to comment