Beyond the ballot: five charts that caught our eye
Few anticipated the scale of the Democrats’ victory in this month’s US midterm elections, which gave the party control of both houses of Congress. The gains reached well beyond the usual battlegrounds, winning seats that had not been held by Democrats for decades. The party had not won a Senate race in Kansas since 1932, nor in Texas since 1988. The swing in the House of Representatives was equally pronounced. The Democrats added more than 40 seats, taking their total above 250 according to the latest count. Neither party has held that many seats since 2008.
Financial markets responded sharply. Equities initially rallied as election uncertainty receded, only for the technology-heavy Nasdaq to record its steepest one-day decline since “Liberation Day” in April 2025, when President Trump’s tariff announcements prompted a global sell-off. The reaction was also evident in other asset classes. The prospect of an earlier end to the war with Iran sent oil prices sharply lower, easing inflation pressures. Combined with demand for safe-haven assets, this pushed the 10-year US Treasury yield close to a two-month low and helped lift gold by almost 5% over the week, its largest weekly gain since August. Much of the repositioning, however, was already under way weeks before the first votes were cast, as higher interest rates, rising inflation and doubts over the returns on AI investment encouraged investors to hold more defensive assets.
When share prices move this abruptly, the natural inclination is to react. We prefer to step back and consider these moves in their broader context. A single day’s trading captures sentiment, whereas the longer-term trends in markets, inflation and policy indicate whether anything fundamental has changed.
The five charts that follow provide that context. They show how investors were positioned ahead of the vote, how inflation shaped both markets and the election result, how the latest sell-off compares with the two that preceded it, where the losses fell and what history suggests may follow.
Bracing for the result
Chart 1: S&P 500 Value index relative to S&P 500 Growth index (upper panel) and monthly percentage change in the ratio (lower panel), October 1996 to November 2026
Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P., via Rothschild & Co Redburn Midweek Charts, 5 November 2026.
In October, value stocks outperformed growth stocks by the widest monthly margin since the early 2000s. We interpret this not so much as an endorsement of value stocks, but as a flight to safety, reflected in the strength of traditionally defensive sectors. The Federal Reserve had raised interest rates in September, the 10-year US Treasury yield had reached its highest level since 2002 in early October, and doubts over the returns on AI investment were mounting. Investors were also preparing for the election. By the eve of the vote, prediction markets implied a probability above 70% that the Democrats would win both houses of Congress.
In our experience, a rotation driven by caution rather than deteriorating fundamentals tends to be less durable, and, on this occasion, the fundamentals remain robust. Corporate profits continue to rise at a healthy pace, and the leading technology companies still see demand far outstripping supply.
Inflation returns to the ballot
Chart 2: US consumer price inflation, year-on-year percentage change, late 2021 to October 2026; the white line shows the increase since September 2025, as no data were collected for October 2025
Source: John Authers, Bloomberg, 11 November 2026.
The rotation in markets was not the only shift under way. Inflation has returned, unsettling investors and voters alike. Having fallen back towards the Federal Reserve’s 2% target at the start of the year, the annual rate has since risen to close to 4%. The Federal Reserve responded by raising rates in September, and Treasury yields climbed further in the weeks that followed. This had a direct impact on growth stocks because higher yields reduce what investors are willing to pay today for future profits. This goes some way towards explaining the rotation into value in our first chart.
For voters, this inflation has meant a rising cost of living, which has long been a decisive force in US politics. Concern over prices helped return President Trump to the White House in 2024 and, on this occasion, counted against him.
Still a shock
Chart 3: FTSE All-World Index and its 200-day moving average, November 2024 to November 2026, rebased to 100 on 5 November 2024 (US election day)
Source: John Authers, Bloomberg, 9 November 2026.
Forewarned though investors were, the scale of the result still took markets by surprise. The chart sets the reaction in context. President Trump’s second term has been an unusually volatile period for investors, and global equities, as measured by the FTSE All-World Index, have fallen sharply three times: following the Liberation Day tariffs of April 2025, which were announced and then suspended within a week; following the air strikes on Iran in February 2026; and now following a midterm defeat that alters the balance of power in Washington.
Yet equities have risen through all of it. The index recovered from the first two declines within a few months, and even after the latest fall it stands roughly a quarter above its level when President Trump was elected. It has slipped below its 200-day moving average, so it is too early to conclude that the decline has run its course, but the past two years have favoured investors who have looked beyond political shocks.
A selective sell-off
Chart 4: S&P 500 and sector performance, percentage change in the week ending 6 November 2026
Source: John Authers, Bloomberg, 9 November 2026.
What stood out about the latest sell-off was how narrow it was. The S&P 500 declined 2.7% in election week, yet five of its 11 sectors finished higher. Information technology declined by close to 7%, extending the rotation away from growth that began in October. Energy broke the pattern. Having led the market in October, the sector lost almost 12% as oil prices retreated on expectations of de-escalation in the Middle East.
Technology’s weakness is easier to understand with some political context. Inflation was not the only issue on voters’ minds. Data centres had become contentious in many states, largely because households are increasingly bearing the cost of powering them, and the administration had made their rapid construction a priority. In exit polls, 56% of voters said AI and data centres had weighed heavily on their choice, and candidates who promised to restrain the expansion won the governorships of Texas, Ohio and Georgia. The sector therefore appears to have been a contributor to the Republicans’ defeat as well as a casualty of it.
What history says about midterms
Chart 5: S&P 500 performance in the 12 months after each US midterm election, percentage change, 1950 to 2022, with the average
Source: Carson Investment Research, YCharts, via Rothschild & Co Redburn Midweek Charts, 14 October 2026.
Unsettling as the past month has been, the period after a midterm election has historically rewarded patience. Since 1950, the S&P 500 has risen in the 12 months following every such vote, by an average of 14.8%. One possible explanation is that the result removes uncertainty, regardless of which party prevails. On this occasion it also brings divided government, which investors have tended to welcome because it limits the extent and pace of policy change. After two years of abrupt shifts, that restraint may prove especially valuable.
Of course, history is a guide rather than a guarantee. Inflation above the target and rising interest rates present a clear headwind. Yet the same was true in 2022, and the S&P 500 still rose 13.6% in the year that followed.
Stepping back
Taken together, the five charts tell a consistent story. The election intensified this month’s volatility but did not create it. Higher interest rates, resurgent inflation and doubts over the returns on AI spending had been unsettling investors for weeks, and the scale of the Democratic victory amplified those concerns.
What matters now is which of these pressures will endure. History suggests the political shock will fade. The sharpest selling it provoked was concentrated in two sectors, and corporate earnings are still growing strongly. Inflation and interest rates, however, are a different matter. They will do more than any vote to determine what investors are prepared to pay for future growth, and the backlash against data centres is a reminder that even the most powerful investment themes depend on public consent.
Our focus therefore remains on companies, rather than Congress. In this environment, we believe the advantage lies with businesses that can fund their own growth and whose valuations do not depend on everything going to plan. That is the standard we will continue to apply to every company we hold, whatever the next two years bring.
5 topics
1 stock mentioned