Yield or Dividend Growth? What ten years of ASX dividends actually paid
On 21 October, Sara Allen asked on Livewire whether Australia’s highest dividend companies are worth buying. It is a fair question, as for a lot of Australian investors, the dividend is the point: it pays the bills, it comes with franking credits, and unlike a growth forecast, it actually arrives.
But a yield table answers only half of it. A yield is a ratio, and it rises for two reasons: the dividend goes up, or the share price goes down. The screen doesn't tell you which, or whether the dividend will still be there in ten years. The dividend record does.
So we went back and checked. We took the dividend payers among the 300 largest ASX companies in October 2015, sorted them by the yield they offered that day, and followed them for a decade.
Our conclusion: a high yield paid more income, but it rarely grew. For every $100 invested, the typical high yielder paid $55 in dividends over the decade, against $33 for the lowest yielders. Yet 58% of the high yielders ended the decade paying a smaller dividend, against two in 22 of the low yielders. By the end, the high yielders' 6.0% starting yield was worth 6.2% on the original price, while the low yielders' 1.7% had grown to 4.8%. The dividends that grew belonged to companies whose earnings grew.
The analysis below starts with today's highest yields, then runs the test forward from 2015.
Behind today's highest yields
We took the 172 dividend payers in the S&P/ASX 300 with a complete record of their last ten annual reports, leaving out property trusts and funds, and sorted them into fifths by Bloomberg consensus forecast yield. Then we reviewed those ten reports, which cover nine years of change.
Today's dividend payers
Among the highest yields, more than a third of dividends have gone backwards: 36% of these companies pay less per share than they did nine years ago. More than a third have paid out more than their free cash flow in at least three of the past five years, which works for a while but not forever. The typical dividend in this group grew 1.5% a year, slower than inflation.
Two cautions. Cuts happen everywhere: 40% of the lowest yielders trimmed their dividend at least once outside the pandemic years, and 76% of the next-highest group did. A low yield is no guarantee either: 39% of the lowest yielders pay less than nine years ago, slightly more than the highest yielders, and their dividends grew barely faster, 1.6% a year against 1.5%. What sets the highest yields apart is the most stretched payouts.
The ten-year test
A backward look at today's high yielders has an obvious flaw. Some of them are high yielders precisely because their share prices fell. So we ran the test forward. We took the dividend payers among the 300 largest ASX companies on 31 October 2015, 213 of them after the data checks below, sorted them by the yield they offered that day, and followed them to 31 October 2025. Another one, CBL Corp, which later failed, paid dividends that year but has no dividend per share in our Bloomberg data, so it is left out.
The income figures use the 119 companies with ten complete, comparable years of dividends. The note under the table explains who is left out.
On income, the high yielders delivered: for every $100 invested, the typical one paid $55 in dividends over the decade, against $33 for the lowest yielders. But their dividends didn't grow. Fourteen of the 24, or 58%, ended the decade paying less per share than in 2015. Among the lowest yielders, 2 of 22 did, and the typical dividend grew 9.8% a year.
That growth adds up: a 1.7% yield in 2015 had become 4.8% on the original price by the end of the decade. The high yielders' income on their original price stayed about where it started.
The middle group is worth a second look. Companies yielding 3.1% to 3.9% in 2015 paid $57 per $100 over ten years, more than the highest yielders, and only 25% ended with a lower dividend, against 58%.
The ten-year test, by 2015 yield
And total return?
Here the answer gets less tidy.
On an equal-weight basis, $1 spread across the lowest-yield fifth in 2015 became $4.71 by 2025, against $3.06 for the highest-yield fifth and $2.52 for the S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index. All five beat the index on that measure. The typical company in every fifth did not.
Those averages rest heavily on single names. Pro Medicus turned $1 into $87 and accounts for more than two-fifths of the lowest-yield fifth's combined result; without it, that fifth's average falls to $2.75, not far above the index's $2.52. Fortescue plays a similar role in the second fifth. Take the single best result out of each fifth and all five land between $2.32 and $2.75.
The median company tells a different story. The typical low yielder turned $1 into just $1.54, and a third of them lost money. The typical high yielder turned $1 into $2.16, and 14% lost money. It is the same lopsided pattern Hendrik Bessembinder found across 90 years of US stocks: a few companies do most of the work.
Twenty-one payers whose dividend per share and cash dividends disagree are left out of every fifth. Fifteen of them lost money, including SpeedCast, which failed. Placed by cash dividends instead, the typical high yielder still beat the typical low yielder, $2.03 against $1.08, and 45% of the lowest yielders and 19% of the highest lost money.
So a low yield is not a strategy on its own, any more than a high yield is. A third of the lowest yielders of 2015 lost money over the decade. What separated the dividends that grew from the ones that shrank?
Dividends followed earnings
Earnings. We took the 80 companies with ten complete years and a profit at both ends, and ranked them by growth in earnings per share.
In the two slowest-growing fifths, 75% and 63% of companies ended the decade paying a lower dividend than in 2015. In the two fastest-growing fifths, 0% and 13% did, and their dividends grew 8.7% and 11.8% a year. The rank correlation between earnings growth and dividend growth was 0.67.
A board can hold a dividend up for a few years by borrowing, or by paying out more than the business earns. Over a decade, the dividend goes where the earnings go.
Accounting professors Douglas Skinner and Eugene Soltes asked what a dividend tells you about the earnings behind it. Their finding was that the reported earnings of dividend payers are more persistent than those of other companies, and that the relationship was "remarkably stable over time" from 1974 to 2005. Dividend payers were also less likely to report losses, and the losses they did report tended to be one-off items (Skinner and Soltes, 2011, Review of Accounting Studies).
A dividend, then, is evidence about the business. A dividend that keeps growing is better evidence still.
Our own holdings
Thirteen companies we hold today were in the 2015 test with complete records. Here is the same yield-on-original-price measure for each.
Lovisa yielded 3.2% in October 2015. Its dividend ten years on, for FY2025, was equal to 22.9% of that 2015 share price. Rio Tinto went from 5.2% to 12.8%, CAR Group from 3.3% to 8.2% and Macquarie from 3.9% to 7.6%. Four of the thirteen now pay more on their 2015 price than the 6.2% median of the highest-yield group.
Two don't flatter us. Corporate Travel Management's latest dividend is worth 0.9% of its 2015 price, below the 1.4% it yielded then. It has declared no dividend since February 2025, after a UK overbilling problem, and its shares were suspended from August 2025 until September 2026. James Hardie yielded 2.5% in October 2015, leaving out special dividends, and replaced its dividend with share buybacks in 2022. Both are in the chart because they are in the data.
The obvious caveat applies. We own these companies today, so the list was chosen with hindsight, and it shows what dividend growth looks like when it compounds. That said, we held seven of them at the end of 2015 too.
What we take from this
Yield is a fair thing to want, but it is only as good as the earnings behind it. The highest yields of 2015 paid more income along the way, yet most of their dividends shrank while the low yielders' grew. Over ten years, the dividends that compounded belonged to the companies whose profits did.
So when we look at a dividend, we start with the business that pays it: what it earns, what it needs to reinvest, and what it is likely to earn in ten years. That leads to the question we take up next: which earnings keep growing?
5 topics
5 stocks mentioned
1 contributor mentioned